
Photo: NHL.com
Auston Matthews Is Right: The Leafs Mirror Has Room for Hiller and Chayka
Table of Contents
Auston Matthews' "Look in the Mirror" Message Is the Right One
Auston Matthews' "look in the mirror" message after Sunday's 4-0 loss to New Jersey was the most direct thing the Maple Leafs captain has said all season, and he is right. "Guys gotta look in the mirror and just ask a little bit more of themselves and take on a little bit more," Matthews said on Nov. 8, per TSN. He acknowledged the injuries. He did not hide behind them.
Toronto is 8-9-2, has lost three straight and has dropped five of six. The captain is the one Leaf who has held up his end, with 27 points in 19 games. So when he says others need to give more, he has earned the right to say it. The harder question is who exactly he means, and whether the people above the players are looking in the same mirror.
The Slide in Numbers
Here is how the last six games have gone. One table tells the story better than any quote:
| Date | Opponent | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Oct. 26 | Calgary Flames | Lost 5-2 |
| Oct. 28 | Seattle Kraken | Lost 5-4 |
| Oct. 31 | Vancouver Canucks | Won 4-2 |
| Nov. 3 | Utah Mammoth | Lost 3-2 |
| Nov. 7 | Montreal Canadiens | Lost 4-2 |
| Nov. 8 | New Jersey Devils | Lost 4-0 |
That is 14 goals for and 23 against, with Toronto's scoring falling off a cliff once Kirill Marchenko was hurt in Calgary. The Leafs have scored four goals in three November games. Toronto has also allowed 45 goals at five-on-five this season, the fourth-most in the NHL, per the Toronto Sun's Terry Koshan. This is not one problem. It is a team that is not scoring and not defending at the same time.
Who Matthews Is Talking To
Matthews did not name names, and he should not have. But the mirror has obvious faces in it.
The second wave of scoring. When Matthews has an off night, nothing replaces him. William Nylander has produced points, but Toronto needs him driving play at five-on-five on the nights Matthews is held in check. We wrote last week that Nylander's scoring pace hides a puck problem, and that problem shows up most when the top line is quiet.
The veterans on the blue line. Morgan Rielly's injury hurts, but the defence was leaking chances before he went down. The players who remain, and who are paid to defend, have to defend.
The depth forwards. With Marchenko, Jack Roslovic and Colton Sissons all hurt or day-to-day, players lower in the lineup are getting minutes they would not get on a healthy team. Hiller said it himself after the Devils game: "We need guys to step up, that's the bottom line," per The Leafs Nation. That is a direct challenge to the players getting those minutes.
Anthony Stolarz made a similar point, saying injuries should not excuse how the team has played, per The Leafs Nation. When the goalie and the captain are saying the same thing, the room has heard it.
The Mirror Has Room for the Coach
Here is where we push back on the narrative that this is purely an effort problem. Jim Hiller has changed his lines almost nightly. Darren Dreger said on TSN 1050 that Marchenko's return would help so Hiller "doesn't have the extra-large blender out there every single night." Some of that shuffling is forced by injuries. Some of it is a coach searching for something that works.
Constant changes make it hard for any player to build chemistry. Hiller's handling of Gavin McKenna has been a debate all fall. We defended him when he benched McKenna and the third period proved him right, but benching rookies and reshuffling veterans only works if the structure underneath is sound. The five-on-five goals-against number says the structure is not.
Hiller does not need to stop holding players accountable. He needs to give them a stable lineup to be accountable within. That means settling on combinations and living with them for more than one game.
And Room for the GM
The last face in the mirror belongs to John Chayka. He told reporters in Calgary on Oct. 26 that he was open to another major trade and that cap space would not be "a gating item." Two weeks later, Toronto has added nothing. The trade talk since has centred on defencemen, even as the team has stopped scoring.
Matthews asking his teammates for more is the right message for a locker room. It is the wrong message for the front office to hide behind. A captain can demand more effort. Only a GM can add a scorer. We made that case Monday: the Leafs need a forward now, not when Marchenko returns. The contracts page shows what Chayka has to work with.
Is Matthews Doing Enough Himself?
Fair question, and the answer is yes. His 27 points in 19 games put him among the league's top scorers, and he was tied for fifth in NHL scoring as of Nov. 6, per The Leafs Nation. We argued last week that Toronto's record isn't on Matthews. That remains true.
The one thing more Toronto could ask of him is defensive impact against the other team's top line, and that is a team-wide problem, not his alone. A captain who scores at nearly a point and a half per game while taking hard matchups is not the problem. He is the reason this is 8-9-2 and not worse.
What a Real Response Looks Like
Words after a loss are cheap. Every team that slumps has a player say something about effort. What matters is whether the next game looks different, and there are specific things to watch for.
A good first period. Toronto has chased too many games. A team answering its captain comes out with pace in the first 10 minutes, wins puck battles and takes the crowd into the game.
Fewer penalties. The Leafs have taken among the most penalties in the league this season, and a tired penalty kill without Colton Sissons cannot keep absorbing them. Discipline is effort too.
Goals from someone other than Matthews. The clearest sign the message landed would be a depth goal, a second-line goal, a defenceman jumping into the rush. If the only offence still runs through the captain, the mirror talk did not change anything.
None of these require a trade or a returning star. They require the players in the lineup to play the way Matthews asked. That is the point of what he said, and the reason it was worth saying in public.
What's Next: Colorado, Minnesota, Edmonton
The response to Matthews' message comes immediately. Toronto hosts the Colorado Avalanche on Tuesday, Nov. 10, then faces Minnesota and Edmonton. Our Avalanche preview breaks down the matchup.
The mirror talk only matters if it shows up on the ice. If Toronto comes out flat against Colorado, the message will have bounced off the room, and the pressure shifts to Hiller and Chayka to make changes the players cannot. If the Leafs respond, Matthews will have done what captains are supposed to do: say the hard thing in public, then lead the answer.
Our take: the captain did his job on Sunday. Now everyone else, from the fourth line to the GM's office, has to do theirs.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Auston Matthews say after the Devils loss?
After the 4-0 loss to New Jersey on Nov. 8, 2026, Matthews said, per TSN, that "guys gotta look in the mirror and just ask a little bit more of themselves and take on a little bit more." He acknowledged the team's injuries but said everyone has to give more.
How many points does Auston Matthews have in 2026-27?
Matthews has 27 points in 19 games through Nov. 8, 2026, leading the Maple Leafs. He was tied for fifth in NHL scoring as of Nov. 6, per The Leafs Nation.
What is the Maple Leafs record in November 2026?
Toronto is 8-9-2 after losses to Utah (3-2), Montreal (4-2) and New Jersey (4-0) in November. The Leafs have lost three straight and five of their last six games.
Who is the Maple Leafs captain?
Auston Matthews is the Maple Leafs captain. He was named captain in August 2024, succeeding John Tavares.
Who is the Maple Leafs head coach?
Jim Hiller is the Maple Leafs head coach. Toronto hired him on June 17, 2026, after Craig Berube was fired in the spring, and John Chayka is the general manager.
Who do the Maple Leafs play next?
Toronto hosts the Colorado Avalanche on Tuesday, Nov. 10, 2026, then faces the Minnesota Wild and the Edmonton Oilers.


