
Photo: NHL.com
Maple Leafs Need a Forward Now: Chayka Cannot Wait for Marchenko
Table of Contents
The Maple Leafs Need a Forward, and They Need One Now
The Maple Leafs need a forward. Not in February, not when Kirill Marchenko comes back, now. Toronto has scored four goals in three November games, was shut out 4-0 by New Jersey on Sunday, Nov. 8, and has lost five of its last six to fall to 8-9-2. Reports after that game said the Leafs have been the lowest-scoring team in the NHL at five-on-five since Marchenko was hurt on Oct. 26. GM John Chayka has spent the fall shopping for a defenceman. The evidence of the last two weeks says he is shopping at the wrong end of the rink.
This is not an argument that the blue line is fine. It is not, and Morgan Rielly's injury makes it worse. It is an argument about order. A team that cannot score more than two goals cannot be saved by a better third pair.
What Chayka Has Said
On Oct. 26 in Calgary, Chayka was asked whether he would make another trade on the scale of the Matthew Knies for Marchenko deal. He said yes. He also said cap space would not stop him. "Every discussion we've had, I don't think that's going to be a gating item for us," he said, per theScore and The Hockey News. He framed a trade as one option among several, and the conversation that day was mostly about improving the team's defending.
We covered those comments at the time in our piece on Chayka's trade plans. Two weeks later, the rumour mill has followed his lead. Names connected to Toronto this fall have mostly been defencemen, from Nashville's blue line to Calgary's Zach Whitecloud, whom David Pagnotta linked to the Leafs. None of that has turned into a deal.
Meanwhile, the team in front of him has changed. In late October, Toronto was a high-scoring team that leaked goals. In November it is a team that cannot score.
The Numbers Since Marchenko Went Down
Marchenko had six goals and 14 points in 14 games before his collision in Calgary. He is listed out until at least Nov. 17, and Darren Dreger said last week he had been told it would be about two more weeks. Here is how Toronto has done in November without him:
| Date | Opponent | Result | Leafs goals |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov. 3 | Utah Mammoth | Lost 3-2 | 2 |
| Nov. 7 | Montreal Canadiens | Lost 4-2 | 2 |
| Nov. 8 | New Jersey Devils | Lost 4-0 | 0 |
Now the forward group is thinner still. Colton Sissons left Sunday's game with a lower-body injury and Jack Roslovic was a late scratch with one of his own. Roslovic had 15 points in his first 15 games. Our injury update has the full list. Even a short absence for both means the Leafs are trying to score with three regulars missing from their top nine.
Matthews Cannot Do It Alone
Auston Matthews leads the team with 27 points and 11 goals in 19 games. That is not the problem. We argued last week that Toronto's record isn't on Matthews, and that has only become more true. He was held without a point against New Jersey for the first time in seven games, and when he has an off night, there is no second wave.
Head coach Jim Hiller has been honest about it. After the Devils loss he said, per The Leafs Nation, "We need guys to step up, that's the bottom line," and acknowledged it is a lot to ask of the young players filling in. That is a coach telling you, politely, that the roster he has been handed is short.
Hiller's response so far has been constant line changes. Dreger said on TSN 1050 that Marchenko's return would help so Hiller "doesn't have the extra-large blender out there every single night." The blender is a symptom. You shuffle lines when no combination works, and no combination works when two of your best scoring wingers are in street clothes.
What Kind of Forward
The target is not a superstar. LeafsLurker has already argued against the big swings, including a Nikita Kucherov trade that would cost the future for a fit that does not solve the depth problem. What Toronto needs is narrower and cheaper:
- A top-six winger who can shoot. Someone who can play with Matthews or Nylander now, and slide to the third line when Marchenko returns.
- Term that works. An expiring deal or one with a year left, so it does not crowd Marchenko's six-year, $12.5 million AAV extension that starts in 2027-28.
- No first-round pick. Toronto's 2027 first is already owed to Boston and its 2028 first to Philadelphia, per the Leafs draft picks page. What the Leafs do hold is Colorado's 2027 first, which is top-10 protected. That is the pick Chayka should be very careful with.
The currency is the issue. With two firsts already gone, Chayka has to pay in prospects, seconds and contracts. Moving Easton Cowan, who has been one of the few young forwards producing, for a rental would be a mistake. Moving a mid-level prospect, a second-round pick or a depth contract for a winger with a year of term would not.
Sunday Was the Proof
The Devils game showed the problem in miniature. Toronto managed 23 shots against Connor Hellebuyck and never led. Hiller reunited John Tavares with Gavin McKenna and William Nylander to try to spread the offence, and in a small sample it did not work. The only special-teams goal of the night belonged to New Jersey.
Stolarz made 25 saves on 28 shots and kept the game within reach for two periods. The Leafs could not use the opening. That is what a team short on finishers looks like: not bad, not outworked every night, just unable to turn decent stretches into goals. Hiller himself said the team needed to score first because it had been hanging around in games and then chasing them. You cannot score first if nobody can score.
The Case Against Waiting
The obvious counter-argument is patience. Marchenko is maybe a week or two away. Roslovic is day-to-day. Get healthy and the offence comes back.
Maybe. But that plan assumes nothing else goes wrong, and this season has already shown how fast that assumption breaks. Toronto has lost Marchenko, Rielly, Sissons, Roslovic, Blankenburg and others in a month. A team that is one injury away from a non-functioning top six needs depth, not optimism. And the standings will not wait. Toronto is seventh in the Atlantic Division with 18 points, and the gap to a playoff spot grows every time the Leafs lose a winnable home game. The standings page has the current picture.
There is also the defence question. Chayka is right that the Leafs need help there, and Rielly's injury raises the urgency. But the defence will look better when Toronto has the puck more, and the fastest way to have the puck more is to have forwards who can keep it.
Our Take
Chayka has shown he will make a bold move. The Knies trade was one. He has also said the cap will not be the thing that stops him. The question now is focus. Every day spent looking for a defenceman who costs a first-round pick is a day Toronto is not scoring.
Add a winger. Do it before the homestand ends against Edmonton on Nov. 14 if he can. Then go back to the blue-line search with a team that can at least give its goalies a lead to protect. Independent, not neutral: the Leafs' most urgent need right now is goals, and the GM should treat it that way.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the Maple Leafs going to make a trade?
Nothing has been announced as of Nov. 9, 2026. GM John Chayka said on Oct. 26 that he was open to another blockbuster trade like the Matthew Knies-for-Kirill Marchenko deal and that cap space would not be a 'gating item.' Most reported talks have centred on defencemen.
How many goals have the Leafs scored in November 2026?
Toronto scored four goals in its first three November games: two in a 3-2 loss to Utah on Nov. 3, two in a 4-2 loss to Montreal on Nov. 7 and none in a 4-0 loss to New Jersey on Nov. 8. The Leafs have not scored more than two goals in a game this month.
When is Kirill Marchenko coming back from injury?
Kirill Marchenko has been out since Oct. 26 with a lower-body injury. Darren Dreger reported he was about two more weeks away, and the latest injury report lists him as out until at least Nov. 17. He had six goals and 14 points in 14 games before the injury.
Who leads the Maple Leafs in scoring?
Auston Matthews leads Toronto with 27 points, including 11 goals, through 19 games of the 2026-27 season. He was held without a point in the 4-0 loss to New Jersey on Nov. 8, ending a six-game point streak.
Do the Maple Leafs have their 2027 first-round pick?
No. Toronto's own 2027 first-round pick is owed to Boston from the March 2025 Brandon Carlo trade. The Leafs do hold Colorado's 2027 first-round pick from the Nicolas Roy trade, which is top-10 protected.
What is the Maple Leafs' record?
Toronto is 8-9-2 with 18 points after its Nov. 8 loss to New Jersey and sits seventh in the Atlantic Division. The Leafs have lost three straight and five of their last six games.


