Skip to main content
Matvei Michkov Stays in Philly: Chayka's Pivot Has to Be Defence

Photo: NHL.com

Opinion

Matvei Michkov Stays in Philly: Chayka's Pivot Has to Be Defence

LeafsLurkerNov 16, 20267 min read

Table of Contents

Matvei Michkov Is Off the Market

Matvei Michkov is not going anywhere. Elliotte Friedman reported on Sportsnet's Saturday Headlines on Nov. 14 that Flyers general manager Daniel Briere and president of hockey operations Keith Jones met with Michkov face to face during Philadelphia's road trip and told him he would not be traded. Friedman added that the front office had canvassed some of the team's younger players about Michkov and the feedback was positive. The plan, he said, is to build around him.

That closes a week of noise that started on Nov. 10, when ESPN's Kevin Weekes reported the 21-year-old wanted a fresh start. Briere called the idea news to him at the time. Now it is settled from the top.

Last week we argued that the Leafs should call anyway and make Philadelphia say no. Philadelphia has said no, publicly and to the player. Our position now is just as plain: John Chayka should take Michkov off his board and point every asset he was willing to spend at the blue line.

Why the Flyers Were Never Going to Sell Cheap

Michkov has 11 goals and 16 points in 22 games, per The Hockey Writers. He is in the final season of his three-year entry-level contract and becomes a restricted free agent in July 2027. That gives the Flyers control. They can qualify him, match any offer sheet, or sign him long term. None of it requires them to trade a 21-year-old who scores like a first-line winger.

The only path to a deal was a player who refused to sign, and Friedman's report suggests the relationship is not there. A team that sends its GM and president to sit down with a player on the road is a team trying to keep him. Any club still pitching Philadelphia on a Michkov trade is now negotiating against the Flyers' own public commitment.

For Toronto in particular, the fit was always strained. The Leafs have little cap room this season and a big jump coming next year, when Kirill Marchenko's six-year extension at a $12.5 million cap hit begins. Michkov's next contract would have landed in the same summer. Chasing him meant paying a premium in assets now and a premium in cap space in 13 months.

The Cap Math Michkov Would Have Run Into

Even if Philadelphia had wavered, the money would have been the next wall. Using the Leafs contracts sheet, Toronto already has roughly $110 million committed to 23 contracts for 2027-28 once Marchenko's raise is counted. That is above this season's $104 million upper limit before anyone fills out the rest of the roster, and before Auston Matthews becomes eligible to sign an extension on July 1, 2027.

Michkov would have needed a new deal in the same window. A 21-year-old with his scoring record is not signing a cheap bridge contract, and arbitration rights and offer-sheet math would have pushed his number toward the top of the market for young wingers. Toronto would have been adding a second major raise on the wing in the same summer it pays Marchenko, with Nylander signed at $11.5 million through 2031-32. That is three big wing contracts and a Matthews negotiation on one cap sheet.

This is the part of the Michkov chase that never fit. The Leafs' cap is tilted toward forwards already. The next significant dollar Chayka commits should go to the position that is costing them games.

Toronto's Real Need Is on the Blue Line

The Leafs' problem in November has not been finding a goal-scoring winger. It has been getting the puck out of their own end. Toronto was outscored 23-9 on its 0-6-0 homestand, and over the first four games of that stretch the Leafs held only 43.45 per cent of the five-on-five expected goals, per Daily Faceoff. That is a team spending its shifts defending.

Chayka appears to agree. Pierre LeBrun reported on TSN this week that the GM keeps making calls about upgrading the defence in a meaningful way, while noting that few teams sell top-four defencemen this early in the season. Friedman went further on the FAN Hockey Show, saying Chayka is not looking for a stopgap but for a defenceman who can be a core piece for years.

Here is what Toronto pays its regular defencemen, per the Leafs contracts sheet (last checked against CapWages on Oct. 3).

DefencemanCap hitSigned throughClause
Darren Raddysh$8.5M2033-34No-move
Morgan Rielly$7.5M2029-30No-move
Chris Tanev$4.5M2029-30No-move
Jake McCabe$4.49M2029-3016-team no-trade list
Oliver Ekman-Larsson$3.5M2027-28Modified no-trade
Troy Stecher$1.35M2027-28None

Rielly has been out with a lower-body injury, Tanev is on a planned load-management schedule, and top prospect Ben Danford broke his wrist with the Marlies. We made the full case in our Maple Leafs defence trade column on Nov. 13. Michkov's news only sharpens it: there is no longer a shiny forward option to split Chayka's attention.

The Colorado Pick Is the Currency

Toronto owns Colorado's 2027 first-round pick from the Nicolas Roy trade of March 2026. It is top-10 protected: if it lands in the top 10, Toronto gets Colorado's 2028 first instead. It is the only first-round pick the Leafs control in 2027 or 2028, according to our Leafs draft pick tracker.

That pick just became more interesting to sellers. Nathan MacKinnon is expected to miss at least a month and Cale Makar about two weeks, as we covered in our look at the Colorado pick. A first from a contender is worth more when the contender is wounded. Friedman's report said the pick is on the table for the right defenceman.

Under the plan we would back, the Colorado first, a prospect, and matching salary go out for a top-four right-shot or left-shot defenceman with term. Not a rental. Toronto has no use for a 10-week fix at 8-12-2; it needs a player who still helps when Matthews is negotiating his next deal.

What Chayka Should Not Do

There are three traps after the Michkov door closes.

  • Chasing the next young forward rumour. The market will produce another one. Columbus has been taking calls on Dmitri Voronkov, for instance. A winger does not fix the defensive-zone problem.
  • Moving Easton Cowan for a short-term defenceman. Cowan is 21, on an entry-level deal through 2027-28, and one of the few cheap contracts Toronto has. Spend him only for a player with years of control.
  • Buying a rental to save the season. Toronto is not one depth defenceman away from a run. It is one real top-four defenceman away from being a playoff team again.

The Michkov saga will be remembered in Philadelphia as a week of drama. In Toronto it should be remembered as the week the forward fantasy ended and the blue-line plan became the only plan.

What's Next

The Leafs play in Chicago on Nov. 17, then return home for the Los Angeles Kings and Columbus Blue Jackets. Marchenko's projected return later this month adds scoring without any trade. If Chayka is going to make a defence deal, the best version happens before the end of November, while the Colorado pick is at peak value and before the Leafs fall too far behind in the Atlantic to make the move matter.

Michkov's next decision is a contract in Philadelphia. Chayka's is a defenceman. Only one of those men is on the clock.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are the Flyers trading Matvei Michkov?

No. Elliotte Friedman reported on Nov. 14, 2026 that Flyers GM Daniel Briere and president of hockey operations Keith Jones met Michkov in person and told him he would not be traded. Philadelphia plans to build around him.

Did Matvei Michkov request a trade?

ESPN's Kevin Weekes reported on Nov. 10 that Michkov would like a fresh start, but there was no report of a formal trade request. Briere said at the time the idea was news to him. The Flyers have since told Michkov he is staying.

How many points does Matvei Michkov have this season?

Michkov has 11 goals and five assists for 16 points in 22 games in 2026-27, per The Hockey Writers. He is in the last season of his three-year entry-level contract and becomes a restricted free agent in July 2027.

How old is Matvei Michkov?

Michkov was born on Dec. 9, 2004, so he is 21 and turns 22 in December 2026. Philadelphia drafted him seventh overall in 2023.

Were the Maple Leafs interested in Matvei Michkov?

There was no confirmed report that Toronto made an offer. LeafsLurker argued on Nov. 11 that the Leafs should ask, but the Flyers have now taken him off the market. Toronto's reported priority under John Chayka is a long-term defenceman.

What draft picks do the Maple Leafs have to trade?

Toronto holds Colorado's 2027 first-round pick from the March 2026 Nicolas Roy trade. It is top-10 protected; if it lands in the top 10, Toronto receives Colorado's 2028 first instead. It is the only first-rounder Toronto controls in 2027 or 2028.

Who is the Maple Leafs GM?

John Chayka is the Maple Leafs' general manager. He was hired in May 2026, replacing Brad Treliving, with Mats Sundin as senior executive adviser. Reports this month say Chayka is trying to trade for a top-four defenceman.

Share this article