
Photo: NHL.com
Maple Leafs Defence Trade: Mid-November Is Here, Chayka Should Pay Now
Table of Contents
The Maple Leafs Defence Trade Clock Has Run Out
On Oct. 8, LeafsLurker argued that John Chayka was right to wait on a Maple Leafs defence trade, but not for long. We gave the blue line until roughly the middle of November to prove it could hold up. It is Nov. 13. The Leafs are 8-11-2, have lost five straight on a homestand, and have been outscored 22-9 in those games. The verdict is in. Chayka should stop shopping and start paying.
He appears to know it. Pierre LeBrun reported on TSN on Nov. 12 that Chayka "continues to make calls about trying to upgrade the blue line in a real way," adding: "This is not about winning or losing or being in a losing streak. But this is a priority item." The catch, per LeBrun, is that "teams aren't really selling on top-four defensemen right now this early in the year."
That last line is the whole argument. When sellers are not selling, buyers have to overpay. Toronto should.
Why the Blue Line Is the Problem
Look at who played defence for Toronto in the 5-2 loss to Minnesota on Nov. 12. Morgan Rielly was out with a lower-body injury. Chris Tanev, 36, was scratched for planned maintenance. Cole McWard was in the lineup. Nick Blankenburg and Marshall Rifai were already injured, and top prospect Ben Danford broke his wrist with the Marlies. Our look at the Leafs defence without Rielly laid out how far down the depth chart that pushes everyone.
Even healthy, this group has a structural gap. Tanev is on a load-management plan that will keep him out of some games all season. That is the right call for a 36-year-old coming off an upper-body injury, and we said so when Chayka made it. But it also means Toronto knowingly plays a chunk of its 84 games without one of its top-four defencemen. Hiller already moved Tanev to the third pair before the Wild game after he and Oliver Ekman-Larsson were caved in by Colorado.
The money is also lopsided. Here is what Toronto pays its regular defencemen, from the Leafs contracts page.
| Defenceman | Cap hit | Signed through | Clause |
|---|---|---|---|
| Darren Raddysh | $8.5M | 2033-34 | No-move |
| Morgan Rielly | $7.5M | 2029-30 | No-move |
| Chris Tanev | $4.5M | 2029-30 | No-move |
| Jake McCabe | $4.49M | 2029-30 | No-trade |
| Oliver Ekman-Larsson | $3.5M | 2027-28 | Modified no-trade |
| Troy Stecher | $1.35M | 2027-28 | None |
That is $29.8 million across six players, four of them with no-move or no-trade protection running to 2030 or beyond. None of the six is a true number-one defenceman in his prime. That is the hole, and it has been since July.
Waiting Until March 1 Is Too Late
The reports around Chayka have pointed to the trade deadline, March 1, as the outer edge of his window. The problem with that timeline is arithmetic. Toronto has 63 games left. Our playoff math put the wild-card line around 93 points. After the Wild loss, the Leafs need about 75 points from those 63 games, a .595 points percentage. They are playing at .429.
Every two weeks of waiting is another six or seven games played with the current group. If the Leafs keep playing at their November rate, by the time a seller emerges in February the season will be too far gone for one defenceman to save it. A trade in late November buys roughly 60 games of impact. A trade on March 1 buys about 20.
There is also a coaching argument. Jim Hiller is 21 games into his tenure, and the hot-seat noise has already started. We have argued that firing Hiller would be the wrong fix. The right one is giving him a defence that can hold a 2-1 lead in the third period, something Toronto did not do against Minnesota.
What Chayka Should Be Willing to Pay
Chayka has been clear about the type of player he wants. Elliotte Friedman reported earlier this fall that the GM is not looking for a Band-Aid solution, and LeBrun's wording this week, an upgrade "in a real way," points the same direction. That means a defenceman under contract beyond this season, someone who fits next to Raddysh or Rielly for years, not a rental.
Players like that cost real assets, especially in November. Here is where we would draw the line:
- Spend the Colorado first. Toronto traded its own 2027 first-round pick but holds Colorado's, per the Leafs draft picks page. A late first from a good team is exactly the currency for this move.
- Add a second-tier prospect. One of the defence or forward prospects behind Danford is fair game.
- Easton Cowan only for the right player. Cowan is on an entry-level deal through 2027-28. He should go only in a deal for a top-pair defenceman in his mid-20s with term.
- Gavin McKenna is off the table. No discussion.
The name that keeps surfacing is Detroit's Simon Edvinsson, and reports have said the Leafs engaged the Red Wings about him earlier this fall. Nothing indicates a deal is close, and Detroit has given no public sign it wants to move him. He is the right type of target, though: young, big, left-shot and long-term. If Chayka cannot get him, he should keep calling until he finds the next player of that profile.
The Cap Is a Hurdle, Not a Wall
Toronto's cap sheet is tight. CapWages listed about $7 million in space when the Leafs' sheet was last checked on Oct. 3, before injuries and roster moves changed the picture. Any significant defenceman is likely to require salary going back the other way.
The obvious candidate is Ekman-Larsson. He carries $3.5 million through 2027-28, has a modified no-trade clause rather than a no-move, and was on the ice for too much of the Colorado and Minnesota damage. Reports earlier this month suggested Chayka was open to moving veteran defencemen to make a deal work. Rielly and McCabe are harder: Rielly's no-move means he controls any move, and McCabe has trade protection. Our earlier piece on a Roman Josi trade explained why Rielly's contract shapes every big defence move Toronto considers.
The Counter-Argument, and Why It Falls Short
The case for patience is real. Rielly should be back soon; TSN's Darren Dreger estimated about a week when the injury happened. Kirill Marchenko will return. Tanev will play more as he regains strength. A healthy Leafs team played well in October, winning four straight on the road, including a 7-2 win in Edmonton.
But that October team still had the same structural problem on defence. It was just hidden by hot goaltending and scoring depth. Injuries did not create the blue-line hole. They exposed it. Waiting for health means betting that a 36-year-old on a managed workload and a 32-year-old with a lower-body injury will cover it for 63 games. That is not a plan.
What's Next for Chayka
The Leafs close the homestand against Edmonton on Saturday, Nov. 14, then visit Chicago on Nov. 17. Chayka does not need to complete a trade by then. He does need to stop treating March 1 as his deadline. The best window to change this season is the next three weeks, while 60 games remain and the playoff line is still reachable.
LeBrun said this is a priority item for Chayka. Priority items get paid for. If a Maple Leafs defence trade costs a first-round pick and a good prospect, that is the price of a playoff season. Not paying it means another spring without one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the Maple Leafs trying to trade for a defenceman?
Yes. Pierre LeBrun reported on TSN on Nov. 12, 2026 that GM John Chayka continues to make calls about upgrading the blue line "in a real way," calling it a priority item. LeBrun added that teams are not really selling top-four defencemen this early in the season.
Who is the Maple Leafs' general manager?
John Chayka has been the Maple Leafs' general manager since May 2026, replacing Brad Treliving. Mats Sundin is the team's senior executive adviser, and Jim Hiller is the head coach.
What first-round picks do the Maple Leafs have in 2027?
Toronto traded its own 2027 first-round pick but owns the Colorado Avalanche's 2027 first-rounder, according to the team's draft-pick tracking. That Colorado pick is Toronto's most likely trade chip for a defenceman.
How much cap space do the Maple Leafs have?
CapWages showed the Leafs with about $7 million in cap space under the $104 million ceiling when LeafsLurker's sheet was last checked on Oct. 3, 2026. Injuries, IR placements and roster moves have changed the picture since, so a major acquisition would likely require sending salary back.
What is Morgan Rielly's contract?
Morgan Rielly carries a $7.5 million cap hit through the 2029-30 season with a full no-move clause, so he would have to approve any trade. He has been out with a lower-body injury since Nov. 7, 2026.
Is Simon Edvinsson available for trade?
Simon Edvinsson has been linked to the Maple Leafs in trade reports, and reports have said Toronto engaged Detroit about him earlier this fall. No deal has been reported, and the Red Wings have not signalled publicly that they want to move him.
Why shouldn't the Leafs wait until the trade deadline?
Reports on Toronto's search have pointed to roughly March 1 as the outer window for a deal. LeafsLurker's view is that waiting that long would leave only about 20 games for a new defenceman to affect the Leafs' playoff chances, versus about 60 games if Chayka acts in late November.


