Photo: Peetlesnumber1, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Jim Hiller Hot Seat: Firing Him 20 Games In Would Be the Wrong Fix
Table of Contents
The Jim Hiller Hot Seat Talk Has Arrived
The Jim Hiller hot seat conversation started earlier than anyone in Toronto expected. The Maple Leafs are 8-10-2 after 20 games, have lost four straight and six of seven, and sat second-last in the Atlantic Division after a 6-3 loss to Colorado on Nov. 10, per The Canadian Press. TSN's Chris Johnston said this week that pressure is being felt across the organization, not only in the front office, according to reports summarizing his comments on TSN's First Up. Columnists have started asking whether Hiller, hired on June 17, 2026, can survive his first season.
Our position: he should, and he will. Firing Hiller 20 games into an 84-game season would be the Leafs doing what they always do, changing the voice behind the bench to avoid admitting the roster isn't good enough. The problems that have sunk this team in November are injuries, a thin blue line and a forward group that cannot score without Kirill Marchenko. None of those are Hiller's doing.
How the Leafs Got Here
Context matters. This is the first season of a new regime. Brad Treliving was fired in the spring, and Craig Berube followed on May 13, 2026, after a 32-36-14 season in which Toronto missed the playoffs. Berube went 84-62-18 across two seasons. GM John Chayka, hired in May, cited the need for an "organizational shift" when he made the move, per NHL.com.
Chayka then rebuilt the roster aggressively. Matthew Knies went to Columbus for Marchenko on Sept. 29. Joseph Woll was traded to Philadelphia in June. Sergei Bobrovsky arrived to share the crease with Anthony Stolarz. Gavin McKenna, the first overall pick, jumped straight to the NHL. That's a lot of change for any coach to absorb in one training camp.
The early results were respectable. Toronto was scoring freely through most of October, with Marchenko a key part of the attack until he was hurt in Calgary on Oct. 26. Since then, the bottom has fallen out.
The Skid in Numbers
Here are the four losses that turned the conversation, all on the current homestand:
| Date | Opponent | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Nov. 3 | Utah Mammoth | Lost 3-2 |
| Nov. 7 | Montreal Canadiens | Lost 4-2 |
| Nov. 8 | New Jersey Devils | Lost 4-0 |
| Nov. 10 | Colorado Avalanche | Lost 6-3 |
That's seven goals for and 17 against. The scoring collapse is the headline. We wrote this week that the Leafs need a forward now, and nothing since has changed that.
Look at who was missing for those games. Marchenko has been out since Oct. 26. Morgan Rielly left the Montreal game hurt and missed the next two. Colton Sissons went down against New Jersey. Chris Tanev is on a managed schedule. Zack MacEwen hurt his wrist against Colorado. Toronto has been icing call-ups like Ryan Tverberg, Cole McWard and Dakota Mermis in roles they would not play on a healthy team.
Where Hiller Deserves Criticism
Being against a firing is not the same as saying Hiller has been perfect. He hasn't.
- The McKenna benching. Hiller sat Gavin McKenna for part of the Nov. 7 loss in Montreal. We argued Hiller got that call right, but it has fed a narrative that he and the team's most important young player are not on the same page.
- Lineup churn. Critics have pointed to constant line shuffling. Some of that is forced by injuries, but the second line around John Tavares and William Nylander has not found a combination that sticks.
- Discipline. Toronto has spent too much time shorthanded this season, and the penalty kill has worn down as a result.
Those are real issues. They are also the kind of thing a coach fixes over a season, not the kind that justify a dismissal in mid-November.
What Hiller Has Said
Hiller has not hidden from the record. After the Colorado loss he said: "We've played a lot of good hockey this year, but our results suck. Our record is what it is, and it's deserved," per The Canadian Press. He also hammered the team for strings of poor decisions, saying a single mistake can be survived but repeated ones from veteran players cannot, per TSN.
That's the right tone. He is holding players accountable publicly without throwing individuals under the bus, and he has backed it with action, moving Chris Tanev to the third pair at practice on Nov. 11. Auston Matthews delivered a similar message after the Devils loss, and we argued then that the mirror has room for Hiller and Chayka too. The captain and coach are saying the same thing. That matters.
Hiller's Track Record
The Leafs knew what they were getting. Hiller went 93-58-24 in 175 games with the Los Angeles Kings after taking over on an interim basis in 2024, and reached the playoffs twice, losing in the first round both times. The Kings fired him on March 1, 2026, with the team at 24-21-14 and three points out of a wild-card spot.
That record says he's a competent regular-season coach who builds structured, defensively sound teams. It doesn't say he's a miracle worker. Chayka hired him knowing that, and a coach who was hired for structure needs healthy defencemen to build structure with.
There is also the cost of a change. Hiller is in the first year of his deal. A firing would mean paying two coaches, bringing in a third system in two seasons and handing McKenna, still a teenager, another new voice in his rookie year.
The Babcock Precedent Doesn't Fit
Those calling for a change will point to recent history. The Leafs fired Mike Babcock on Nov. 20, 2019, with the team at 9-10-4, and Sheldon Keefe went 27-15-5 the rest of the way. On the surface, an 8-10-2 start looks like the same movie.
It isn't. Babcock was in his fifth season, coaching a roster built around his priorities, and the room had clearly stopped responding. Toronto was mostly healthy when it made the change. Hiller is 20 games into his first season with a roster that was reshaped weeks before opening night, and he has been without his best winger, his top defenceman and two regular centres for long stretches.
A new coach in 2019 unlocked a talented group that was underperforming. A new coach in 2026 would inherit the same injury list, the same thin blue line and the same lack of scoring depth. The fix would last as long as the next injury.
The Real Pressure Point Is Chayka
If the organization is feeling heat, the GM has more levers than the coach. Toronto is paying big money for depth: Colton Sissons ($4.25 million), Nick Paul ($3.15 million), Brandon Duhaime ($2.6 million) and Teddy Blueger ($2.5 million) together cost $12.5 million against the cap, per our contracts page. That's a lot of money for a group that is not driving offence. Bobrovsky at $7 million through 2028-29 is another big bet that has not yet paid off.
Chayka said on Oct. 26 that he was open to another big trade and that cap space would not stop him. Three weeks later, there has been no move. The Leafs have been linked to defencemen around the league, but the injuries have turned a want into a need. Chayka acting before the trade market tightens would do more for the record than a coaching change.
What's Next for Hiller and the Leafs
The next few weeks will decide how loud this gets. Toronto hosts Minnesota on Nov. 12, Marchenko is week-to-week, and Rielly is day-to-day. A healthy Leafs team under Hiller deserves to be judged on its own. An injured one shouldn't cost him his job.
Our bar: if the Leafs are healthy by early December and still sitting in the bottom three of the Atlantic, the conversation changes. Until then, the Jim Hiller hot seat is a symptom of a roster problem. Fix the roster first. Track where Toronto sits on our standings page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Jim Hiller on the hot seat?
Jim Hiller faces growing pressure after the Maple Leafs started 8-10-2 through 20 games of the 2026-27 season, including four straight losses. TSN's Chris Johnston has reported that pressure is being felt across the organization. There has been no report that the Leafs are considering firing Hiller, who was hired on June 17, 2026.
When did the Maple Leafs hire Jim Hiller?
The Maple Leafs hired Jim Hiller as head coach on June 17, 2026. He replaced Craig Berube, who was fired on May 13, 2026, after Toronto missed the playoffs with a 32-36-14 record. Hiller was the first coaching hire of GM John Chayka.
Why did the Kings fire Jim Hiller?
The Los Angeles Kings fired Jim Hiller on March 1, 2026, after the team lost five of six games and fell out of playoff position at 24-21-14. He finished 93-58-24 in 175 games with Los Angeles and made the playoffs twice, losing in the first round both times. D.J. Smith took over as interim coach.
What is the Maple Leafs' record in 2026-27?
The Maple Leafs were 8-10-2 after 20 games, entering their Nov. 12, 2026 home game against the Minnesota Wild. They had lost four straight and six of their last seven. The Canadian Press had them second-last in the Atlantic Division.
What did Jim Hiller say after the loss to Colorado?
After the 6-3 loss to Colorado on Nov. 10, 2026, Hiller said, "We've played a lot of good hockey this year, but our results suck. Our record is what it is, and it's deserved," per The Canadian Press. He also criticized repeated poor decisions by veteran players.
Who is the Maple Leafs general manager?
John Chayka is the Maple Leafs general manager. He was hired in May 2026 after Brad Treliving was fired, and Mats Sundin joined as a senior executive adviser. Chayka's major moves include trading Matthew Knies to Columbus for Kirill Marchenko on Sept. 29, 2026.


