
Photo: NHL.com
Maple Leafs Scoring Drought: October's Shooting Luck Ran Out
Table of Contents
The Maple Leafs Scoring Drought in One Number
The Maple Leafs scoring drought is easy to measure. Toronto scored 60 goals in its first 16 games, 3.75 per game, and went 8-6-2. It then scored nine goals in six games on a homestand from Nov. 3 to Nov. 14, 1.5 per game, and lost all six. The Leafs now have 69 goals in 22 games, 3.14 per game, which NHL.com listed this week. They were fourth in the NHL in goals per game at the end of October and had dropped to 14th before the Edmonton loss, per Maple Leafs Hot Stove.
The temptation is to call the homestand a slump that will pass. Part of it will. But the data from October said this team was not a 3.75-goals-a-game team in the first place, and pretending otherwise is how the Leafs end up making the wrong fix.
What October Was Hiding
In early November, Maple Leafs Hot Stove's notebook laid out the underlying numbers. Toronto ranked seventh in the league in shooting percentage and 27th in five-on-five save percentage. It was 26th in shot-attempt share and 22nd in expected goals share. Put simply, the Leafs were scoring on a lot of their chances and allowing a lot of goals, while losing the territorial battle most nights.
That profile is not stable. Shooting percentage swings hard over small samples, and a team that ranks in the bottom third in expected goals cannot count on finishing at a top-seven rate for 84 games. When the shots stop going in, what is left is a team that spends too much time in its own zone.
The table below shows how the picture changed between the two stretches.
| Stretch | Games | Goals for | Goals per game | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First 16 games (through Vancouver) | 16 | 60 | 3.75 | 8-6-2 |
| Nov. 3 to Nov. 14 (homestand) | 6 | 9 | 1.50 | 0-6-0 |
| Season to date | 22 | 69 | 3.14 | 8-12-2 |
Neither of the top two rows is the real team. The truth is somewhere around the season average, and the expected-goals data says that average is probably still a little generous.
The Homestand Was Not Just Bad Luck
If the homestand were only cold shooting, the Leafs would have been out-chancing teams and losing anyway. They were not. Over the first four games, Toronto was outscored 17-7 and held 43.45 per cent of the five-on-five expected goals, per Daily Faceoff. Toronto was outscored 6-1 in first periods during the five losses before Edmonton, per Maple Leafs Hot Stove, which meant chasing games against good defensive teams.
The opponents matter too. Utah, Montreal, New Jersey, Colorado, Minnesota and Edmonton is a hard six-game stretch, and two of those teams shut Toronto out: New Jersey 4-0 on Nov. 8 and Edmonton 1-0 on Nov. 14. In the Edmonton game the Leafs had 19 shots on goal. You do not score much when you only get 19 shots.
Special teams are not the excuse. Entering the Oilers game the Leafs' power play was at 27.1 per cent, seventh in the NHL, and the penalty kill was at 85.5 per cent, also seventh. The drought is a five-on-five problem.
Who Is Carrying It and Who Is Not
Auston Matthews has 29 points in 22 games. That is a point-per-game-plus season on a team that has lost 14 of 22, and it is why we said earlier this month that the record is not on Matthews.
William Nylander is a harder case. He has 22 points in 22 games, which looks fine, but he is minus-8 and had one shot on goal in 19:55 against Edmonton. Nylander's value has always been that he creates offence on his own. When his shot volume dries up, the second line stops driving play, and the Leafs become a one-line team.
The depth has been hit hardest by injuries. Kirill Marchenko has been on injured reserve since late October, Colton Sissons is on IR, and Hiller has cycled Marlies call-ups through the bottom six. Gavin McKenna has six goals as an 18-year-old rookie, which is good, but he is not yet a player who can drive a line against top competition.
The Fix Starts in the Defensive Zone
The instinct after nine goals in six games is to buy a scorer. We argued earlier this month that the Leafs needed a forward, and the depth is still thin. But the bigger lesson from the shot data is that Toronto loses the puck battle before it gets to the offensive zone. A team at the bottom of the league in shot-attempt share does not become a scoring team by adding one winger.
The higher-leverage move is a top-four defenceman who can retrieve pucks and make the first pass under pressure. That turns 20-second defensive-zone shifts into clean exits, and clean exits are where Matthews, Nylander and McKenna get their chances. It is also what John Chayka is reportedly shopping for, which we covered in our defence trade column.
Internally, Hiller has two levers. The first is pairing Nylander with a puck-retrieving centre rather than another skill player, to restore his shot volume. The second is McKenna's minutes. A rookie with six goals in 22 games has earned more offensive-zone starts on a team scoring 1.5 a game.
How the Opponents Shaped the Numbers
Context matters for a six-game sample, so here is the homestand opponent by opponent. Toronto played two of the West's best teams in Colorado and Edmonton, an Atlantic rival in Montreal that was riding a 10-game point streak, and a Minnesota team that beat them by three. The Leafs did not lose to bad teams. They lost to good ones in ways that showed their weaknesses.
| Date | Opponent | Result | Toronto goals |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov. 3 | Utah Mammoth | Lost 3-2 | 2 |
| Nov. 7 | Montreal Canadiens | Lost 4-2 | 2 |
| Nov. 8 | New Jersey Devils | Lost 4-0 | 0 |
| Nov. 10 | Colorado Avalanche | Lost 6-3 | 3 |
| Nov. 12 | Minnesota Wild | Lost 5-2 | 2 |
| Nov. 14 | Edmonton Oilers | Lost 1-0 | 0 |
The pattern is consistent. Toronto never scored more than three goals in a game and fell behind early often enough to be chasing all night. Against Utah and Edmonton the Leafs were within a goal at the end. Against Colorado and Minnesota they were not close. That is what a team with poor five-on-five process looks like once its shooting regresses: competitive on good nights, overwhelmed on bad ones.
What Not to Read Into It
A six-game sample is still six games. Toronto was not as good as 3.75 goals per game in October, and it is not as bad as 1.5 a game in November. The Leafs will score again, probably soon, against a Chicago team that has allowed plenty of leads to slip, including a 4-0 lead against Winnipeg on Nov. 14.
The point is that the October version of this team was flattered by finishing. If Toronto plans its season around getting back to that version, it will be disappointed again. If it plans around the expected-goals version, it will fix the defence.
What's Next
The Leafs play at Chicago on Nov. 17, then come home for the Los Angeles Kings and Columbus Blue Jackets. Marchenko is projected back in the second half of November, which adds a 30-goal-calibre winger without a trade. Watch two numbers over the next five games: shots on goal per game and five-on-five expected goals share. If both climb, the goals will follow. If they don't, the drought was never about luck.
Follow the race on the Atlantic Division standings and individual numbers on our Leafs player pages.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many goals did the Maple Leafs score on their homestand?
Toronto scored nine goals in six home games from Nov. 3 to Nov. 14, 2026, and lost all six. The Leafs were outscored 23-9 and were shut out twice, 4-0 by New Jersey and 1-0 by Edmonton.
How many goals per game do the Maple Leafs average in 2026-27?
The Leafs have 69 goals in 22 games, an average of 3.14 per game. They averaged 3.75 per game over their first 16 games before scoring nine in the next six. They ranked fourth in goals per game at the end of October and 14th entering the Nov. 14 game.
Why have the Maple Leafs stopped scoring?
Their October scoring was boosted by a top-seven shooting percentage while they ranked 26th in shot-attempt share and 22nd in expected goals share. When shooting cooled off, the poor territorial numbers showed. Injuries to Kirill Marchenko and Colton Sissons have also thinned the forward group.
Is the Maple Leafs' power play the problem?
No. Entering the Nov. 14 game against Edmonton, Toronto's power play was converting at 27.1 per cent, seventh in the NHL, and its penalty kill was at 85.5 per cent, also seventh. The drop in scoring has come at five-on-five.
How many points does Auston Matthews have this season?
Matthews has 29 points in 22 games in 2026-27. He has stayed productive through the losing streak and is the Leafs' leading scorer.
When do the Maple Leafs play next?
Toronto plays the Chicago Blackhawks on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026 at the United Center at 7:30 p.m. ET. The Leafs then return home to face the Los Angeles Kings and the Columbus Blue Jackets.


