
Photo: NHL.com
Auston Matthews Has 26 Points in 17 Games. The 8-7-2 Isn't on Him
Table of Contents
Auston Matthews Is Doing His Job
Auston Matthews has 11 goals and 15 assists for 26 points in 17 games this season, which puts him in the top five in NHL scoring heading into the weekend. Only Connor McDavid (40), Leon Draisaitl (29) and Evan Bouchard (28) had more in the Associated Press scoring list published this week, with Matthews tied with Minnesota's Kirill Kaprizov. Nine of his 26 points have come on the power play.
The Leafs are 8-7-2. That gap — a captain producing at an elite rate on a team hovering around .500 — is going to produce a lot of talk this month about what is wrong in Toronto. Some of it will drift toward Matthews, because it always does. It should not. The 8-7-2 is not on him, and the Leafs should spend November fixing the things that are actually broken instead of looking at the top line.
The Pace, in Plain Numbers
Projections after 17 games are loose, but the shape is worth seeing. Here is what Matthews' current rates would produce over a full 82-game season.
| Category | Through 17 GP | 82-game pace |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | 11 | 53 |
| Assists | 15 | 72 |
| Points | 26 | 125 |
| Power-play points | 9 | 43 |
| Shots | 51 | 246 |
There is one caution in that table. Eleven goals on 51 shots is a 21.6% shooting percentage, which is high even for one of the best finishers in the world. If that cools off, the goal pace drops into the 40s. But the assist pace is doing a lot of the work here, and that part of his game is less dependent on the puck going in at an unusual rate. Even with regression, this is a point-a-game-plus season.
He is also doing it without a fixed cast. Kirill Marchenko has been out since Oct. 27. John Tavares has been out since mid-October. Matthews' most regular partners have been Jack Roslovic and Easton Cowan, and when Roslovic took a maintenance day on Nov. 4, Vinni Lettieri took his spot at practice.
Where the Losses Actually Come From
Toronto had 62 goals for and 55 against through 17 games. That is a +7 differential, and the 62 goals ranked near the top of the league. A team scoring like that should not be hovering around .500. The problem is on the other side of the ledger: 55 goals against ranked in the bottom third.
Two causes stand out.
- Goaltending. Sergei Bobrovsky is 3-6-2 with an .885 save percentage and a 3.29 goals-against average, per figures reported by The Globe and Mail. Anthony Stolarz is 5-1-0 with a .910 and a 2.66. One of those is a starting-goalie line. The other is not.
- Penalties. Toronto had taken 75 penalties through 17 games, second in the NHL behind Montreal, per one count published this week. The penalty kill has been excellent at 88.1%, but the late penalties have still decided games. We broke that down in our look at the Maple Leafs' penalty problem.
Neither of those has anything to do with Matthews. In the Nov. 3 loss to Utah, he assisted on both Toronto goals — Roslovic scored twice — and the game turned on a Darren Raddysh cross-check in the third that led to Nick Schmaltz's power-play winner. Bobrovsky made 33 saves that night. Matthews did his part; the team lost anyway.
The Bad Habit: Blaming the Top Line
Every Leafs slump of the last decade has eventually come around to the same argument: the stars do not do enough when it matters. That is a fair argument in April. It is a lazy one in November when the star is tied for fourth in league scoring.
The risk is not that fans complain. The risk is that the organization reacts to a .500 record by tinkering with the part that works. Breaking up Matthews and Roslovic to "spread the scoring" would be exactly that. So would a trade built around adding another forward when the forward group is already producing. We made the case for keeping that pairing together in our Roslovic column, and nothing in the last week changes it.
The same goes for the trade market. Nikita Kucherov's trade request has dominated the rumour cycle for a week. Adding another elite winger would be fun. It would not fix a save percentage or a penalty count, and it would cost the kind of assets Toronto needs for a defenceman or a goaltending answer if Bobrovsky does not turn it around.
What John Chayka Should Take From This
Matthews carries a $13.25 million cap hit through 2027-28 with a no-move clause, per the LeafsLurker contracts page. He becomes eligible to sign an extension on July 1, 2027. After a spring of uncertainty about his future, Matthews told reporters at training camp in September that his "intent was always to be here," per TSN, and said he liked the moves John Chayka made over the summer. The background is in our Matthews contract piece.
If both sides want this to continue, then this season is the first piece of evidence for both sides of that negotiation. Matthews turned 29 on Sept. 17. A 120-plus point pace at 29 strengthens his hand. It also raises the cost of wasting his prime on a team that loses one-goal games to goaltending and the penalty box. The best thing Chayka can do for a future extension is make sure Matthews spends the next two seasons on a team that wins when he produces.
That means three things, in order:
- Let the goalie with the better numbers start more often until Bobrovsky earns the net back.
- Hold the defence to cleaner exits and fewer third-period minors.
- Get Tavares and Marchenko healthy and back in the lineup before making any trade at forward.
The Honest Counterpoint
There is a fair version of the critique. Matthews' line has to win its matchups at even strength, not just on the power play, and nine of his 26 points have come with the man advantage. The power play has been a strength, at roughly 28.8% entering this week, so some of that production is the unit as a whole doing its job.
The shooting percentage is also likely to come down, and when it does, there will be a stretch of games where he is getting chances and not scoring. That is when the noise will start. It will be worth remembering then that the process is what matters: 51 shots in 17 games is three a night, which is a volume that keeps producing goals over a season even when the percentage normalizes.
None of that changes the main point. The captain is doing what the captain is paid to do.
What's Next: A Weekend That Tests the Rest of the Roster
Toronto hosts Montreal on Saturday, Nov. 7, and New Jersey on Sunday, Nov. 8, a back-to-back at Scotiabank Arena. Our full matchup breakdown is in the Maple Leafs vs Canadiens preview. The Canadiens are 10-3-3 with Nick Suzuki back. The Devils have Connor Hellebuyck.
Matthews will probably produce in one or both. Whether Toronto gets four points out of the weekend will depend far more on who is in goal, whether Tavares is back, and how many minors the Leafs take after the second intermission. That is the honest scorecard for November — and it is not the one with Matthews' name at the top. Track his numbers and the rest of the roster on our players page.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many points does Auston Matthews have this season?
Auston Matthews had 11 goals and 15 assists for 26 points in 17 games through Nov. 3, 2026. Nine of those points came on the power play. He was tied with Kirill Kaprizov behind Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and Evan Bouchard in the NHL scoring race.
What is Auston Matthews on pace for in 2026-27?
Through 17 games, Matthews was on pace for roughly 53 goals and 125 points over 82 games. His 21.6% shooting percentage on 51 shots is high, so the goal pace may come down. Early-season paces are rough estimates, not predictions.
Who leads the NHL in points in 2026-27?
Connor McDavid led the NHL with 40 points in 16 games in the Associated Press scoring list published in early November 2026. Leon Draisaitl was second with 29 and Evan Bouchard third with 28. Auston Matthews and Kirill Kaprizov had 26 each.
When does Auston Matthews' contract expire?
Matthews' contract carries a $13.25 million cap hit and runs through the 2027-28 season, with a no-move clause. He becomes eligible to sign an extension with Toronto on July 1, 2027, and would otherwise be an unrestricted free agent in July 2028.
How old is Auston Matthews?
Auston Matthews was born on Sept. 17, 1997, so he is 29 years old during the 2026-27 season. He has played his entire NHL career with the Toronto Maple Leafs since being drafted first overall in 2016.
Why are the Maple Leafs 8-7-2 with Matthews scoring so much?
Toronto had a +7 goal differential (62 for, 55 against) through 17 games, but goals against ranked in the bottom third. Sergei Bobrovsky was 3-6-2 with an .885 save percentage, and the Leafs had taken the second-most penalties in the league. Two one-goal losses were decided by power-play goals off late Toronto penalties.


