Skip to main content
Maple Leafs Penalties: Second-Most in the NHL, and the PK Is Tiring

Photo: NHL.com

Opinion

Maple Leafs Penalties: Second-Most in the NHL, and the PK Is Tiring

LeafsLurkerNov 6, 20267 min read

Table of Contents

Maple Leafs Penalties: The Number Behind 8-7-2

The Maple Leafs penalties problem is no longer a talking point — it is a standings problem. Through 17 games, Toronto had taken 75 penalties, second in the NHL behind only the Montreal Canadiens at 78, according to a count published this week. That works out to about 4.4 penalties a game. The Leafs are 8-7-2, and at least two of those losses were decided by a goal that came directly off a Toronto minor in the third period.

The reason it has not become a full crisis is the penalty kill. Toronto was killing penalties at 88.1% entering this week, fourth in the league. That number is real and it reflects good work. It is also the reason this has been easy to wave off. A team that takes this many penalties is asking its penalty kill to be elite every night, and no penalty kill stays elite on that workload all season.

Jim Hiller has been saying this since opening week. The question now is whether anything changes before Saturday, when the two most-penalized teams in the league meet at Scotiabank Arena.

Two Losses That Came Straight From the Box

The clearest way to see the cost is to look at the games. Here are the two one-goal losses where a late Toronto penalty led straight to the winning goal.

DateOpponentPenaltyResult
Oct. 3Ottawa SenatorsKirill Marchenko high-stick on Tim Stutzle, 7:46 of the thirdStephen Halliday scores at 9:46, Ottawa wins 3-2
Nov. 3Utah MammothDarren Raddysh cross-check on Barrett Hayton, third periodNick Schmaltz scores on the power play at 13:12, Utah wins 3-2

After the Ottawa loss, Hiller pointed to "careless penalties" and singled out the two third-period calls, per The Leafs Nation. That was also the night Toronto hit six posts, which is why the game got remembered as bad luck. It was not only bad luck. We covered that one in our recap of the Senators loss.

After the Utah loss on Nov. 3, Hiller was blunter. He called Raddysh's cross-check a "stupid penalty" that cost the team its momentum, per TSN, and Raddysh said he took the blame. Jack Roslovic had just tied the game 2-2 at 9:05 of the third. Toronto had the push. The penalty handed it back to a Utah team with the league's top power play. The full sequence is in our Mammoth game recap.

Who Is Taking Them

The same count that had Toronto second in the league listed Easton Cowan and Oliver Ekman-Larsson with seven penalties each and Zack MacEwen with six. Those three account for 20 of the 75. The other 55 are spread around the roster, which is the more worrying part: this is not one player's habit, it is a team pattern.

PlayerPenaltiesRole
Easton Cowan7Top-six wing, second NHL season
Oliver Ekman-Larsson7Veteran defenceman
Zack MacEwen6Fourth-line enforcer

MacEwen's number is the easiest to live with. He is on the roster partly to be physical, and some of his minors come with coincidental calls or as the cost of answering a hit. Cowan's is more interesting. His game is built on pressure — he hunts pucks, finishes checks and plays on the edge. That is a big part of why he has worked with Auston Matthews. But seven minors from a winger playing top-six minutes is a lot of time Matthews spends on the bench watching the penalty kill.

Ekman-Larsson's seven are the ones Hiller should care about most. A veteran defenceman taking that many is usually a sign of a player getting beaten and reaching — hooks, holds and trips after a step has been lost. That is a usage question as much as a discipline one.

Hiller's Diagnosis: Turnovers First, Penalties Second

Hiller has tied the penalties to something upstream. His explanation, per The Leafs Nation, is that tired players take penalties after giveaways in their own end. A puck gets turned over, the shift extends, legs go, and the stick comes out. That fits the pattern in both losses above — neither penalty was a hockey-play foul in the offensive zone. Both came in or near Toronto's end late in a game.

It also fits the bigger picture of an uneven start, which we looked at in our look at Hiller's November test. Inconsistent puck management produces long defensive-zone shifts, and long defensive-zone shifts produce penalties. The penalty count is a symptom.

That diagnosis is right, but it is also a little too comfortable. Some of these penalties are just decisions. Raddysh's cross-check came while he was wrestling his stick back from Hayton, who was down on the ice. Fatigue did not make him do that. Marchenko's high stick on Stutzle was a stick-control error. Those are the ones a coach can change with ice time.

Why the Penalty Kill Will Not Keep Bailing Them Out

Here is the math. The same count had Toronto shorthanded 59 times. At 88.1%, that is about seven power-play goals against in 17 games. That is a very good rate. But move the kill to a league-average rate, somewhere around 80%, and the same 59 chances produce about 12 goals against instead of seven. Five extra goals over 17 games is the difference between a +7 goal differential and a +2.

Penalty-kill percentages swing hard over small samples. A kill that is fourth in the league in early November can be 15th by Christmas without anyone playing worse — the bounces simply even out. The only part of the equation the Leafs fully control is the number of times they are shorthanded. That is where the fix has to come from.

There is also a cost that does not show up on the penalty-kill line. Every two minutes in the box is two minutes Toronto's best offensive players spend mostly on the bench while the penalty killers work. A team that takes four-plus minors a game is shaving several minutes a night off its most dangerous skaters. For a team with 62 goals in 17 games, that is the wrong trade.

Our Take: Make It Cost Ice Time

Hiller has said the right things. It is time for consequences. Not a public benching for a young player like Cowan, who is producing and whose edge is part of his value. But the next veteran who takes an offensive-zone stick infraction or a retaliation minor in the third period of a one-goal game should see his next shift come off the clock. Coaches have done this forever because it works.

The second fix is structural. If Hiller is right that the penalties start with giveaways, then the defence pairs need simpler exits. Raddysh, on a contract that runs through 2034 at $8.5 million a year, has to be the first one held to that standard, and he already took the blame himself on Nov. 3. Accepting blame is the easy part.

The third fix is selection. If MacEwen's role is to answer for teammates, fine. If his minutes are producing more penalties than hits that change a game, the Leafs have other bottom-six options to look at.

What's Next: Montreal, the Only Team Worse at This

Saturday's game against the Canadiens is the perfect test. Montreal is the only team in the league that has taken more penalties than Toronto, which means both power plays should see plenty of time. Montreal just got Nick Suzuki back to rejoin Cole Caufield on its top unit, and Caufield scored twice on the power play against Winnipeg on Nov. 3. Toronto's power play has been good too, at roughly 28.8% entering the week.

The team that stays out of the box in the third period probably wins. Our full matchup breakdown is in the Maple Leafs vs Canadiens preview. Then comes Sunday against New Jersey on the second night of a back-to-back — exactly the kind of tired-legs game Hiller says produces the penalties in the first place.

The Leafs do not need to become a team that never takes a penalty. They need to stop being the second-worst in the league at it. Getting from 4.4 a game to closer to three would take pressure off a penalty kill that has carried more than its share, and it would put Auston Matthews and William Nylander back on the ice where they belong.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many penalties have the Maple Leafs taken this season?

Toronto had taken 75 penalties through its first 17 games of 2026-27, according to a count published in early November. That ranked second in the NHL behind the Montreal Canadiens, who had 78. It works out to roughly 4.4 penalties per game.

What is the Maple Leafs' penalty kill percentage?

The Leafs' penalty kill was at 88.1% entering the week of Nov. 2, 2026, ranked fourth in the NHL. That works out to about seven power-play goals allowed on 59 times shorthanded. The strong kill has offset Toronto's high penalty count so far.

Which Maple Leafs players take the most penalties?

Easton Cowan and Oliver Ekman-Larsson led the team with seven penalties each through 17 games, with Zack MacEwen next at six, per one count published this week. Those three account for 20 of Toronto's 75 penalties.

What did Jim Hiller say about Darren Raddysh's penalty?

After the 3-2 loss to the Utah Mammoth on Nov. 3, 2026, Hiller called Raddysh's third-period cross-check a 'stupid penalty' that cost Toronto its momentum, as reported by TSN. Nick Schmaltz scored the winning power-play goal off it with 6:48 left. Raddysh said he took the blame.

Why did the Leafs lose to the Senators on Oct. 3?

Ottawa won 3-2 after Kirill Marchenko took a high-sticking penalty on Tim Stutzle at 7:46 of the third period, and Stephen Halliday scored the winner at 9:46. Toronto also hit six posts that night. Hiller blamed 'careless penalties' afterward.

Which NHL team takes the most penalties in 2026-27?

The Montreal Canadiens led the NHL with 78 penalties as of early November 2026, with the Maple Leafs second at 75, per a count published this week. The two teams meet at Scotiabank Arena on Saturday, Nov. 7.

Share this article