
Photo: Андрей Чудаев, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Maple Leafs vs. Mammoth: Raddysh Penalty, Schmaltz Winner Sink Toronto 3-2
Table of Contents
Maple Leafs vs Mammoth: the result
The Maple Leafs vs. Mammoth rematch went the same way as the first one. The Utah Mammoth beat Toronto 3-2 at Scotiabank Arena on Tuesday, Nov. 3, with Nick Schmaltz scoring the winner on a power play with 6:48 left in regulation. The penalty that set it up belonged to Darren Raddysh, who cross-checked Barrett Hayton less than four minutes after Toronto had tied the game.
Jack Roslovic scored both Toronto goals, Auston Matthews assisted on both, and Sergei Bobrovsky made 33 saves in his return to the net. It was not enough. Toronto fell to 8-7-2 and 18 points, and the six-game homestand that was supposed to steady the season opened with a regulation loss. Utah improved to 10-6-0.
Utah also won the first meeting, 5-4 on Oct. 13, which we covered in our recap of the loss in Utah. Two games, two one-goal losses, and the Mammoth have now beaten the Leafs with rush goals once and with special teams the second time.
How the goals went in
Utah scored first, and late. Dylan Guenther put the Mammoth ahead on the power play at 19:47 of the first period. Roslovic answered at 10:20 of the second off a Matthews feed. Andrew Peeke then restored Utah's lead at 13:42 of the second with a point shot through traffic that beat Bobrovsky, a goal Toronto never challenged even though Hayton had bumped the goalie on the play.
Here is the scoring summary, compiled from the NHL.com and Canadian Press game reports:
| Period | Time | Team | Goal | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | 19:47 | Utah | Dylan Guenther | Power play |
| 2nd | 10:20 | Toronto | Jack Roslovic | Assisted by Matthews |
| 2nd | 13:42 | Utah | Andrew Peeke | Point shot through traffic |
| 3rd | 9:05 | Toronto | Jack Roslovic | Backhand on a breakaway |
| 3rd | 13:12 | Utah | Nick Schmaltz | Power play, game-winner |
The tying goal was the best moment of Toronto's night. Matthews sent Roslovic in alone on Sebastian Cossa, and Roslovic finished with a backhand at 9:05 of the third. The building was loud, the Leafs were pressing, and for a few minutes the game looked like it was turning.
The Raddysh penalty that decided it
Then it turned back. Raddysh and Hayton got tangled, Hayton went down, and while Raddysh was wrestling his stick free he delivered a cross-check to the Utah centre on the ice. The referees called it. On the power play that followed, Bobrovsky made a big stop on Clayton Keller, the rebound sat in the crease, and Schmaltz buried it.
Head coach Jim Hiller did not soften it afterward. According to TSN's postgame report, he called it a "stupid penalty" and said: "Let's call it what it is, and it costs us. Thought we had all the momentum … didn't turn out very well for us." Raddysh took it on himself, telling reporters he "took a dumb penalty, so I take the blame for that one."
Hiller also said he did not see it as a pattern, describing it as "a one-off I guess in his case." That is fair as far as discipline goes; Raddysh came into the night with six penalty minutes in 16 games. The bigger worry about Toronto's highest-paid defenceman is the other end of the ice, which we get into in our column on Raddysh's goal drought.
Bobrovsky bounced back, and it still was not enough
Hiller started Bobrovsky over a hot Anthony Stolarz, and we argued before the game that the goalie plan was the wrong split. To be fair to Bobrovsky, this was one of his better nights of the season. He stopped 33 of 36 shots, made the save on Keller that could have ended things earlier, and was beaten by a power-play goal off the opening shot, a screened point shot and a crease rebound on a second power play.
He also lost again, and he is now 3-6-2. That is the uncomfortable thing about the crease right now: a .917 night from Bobrovsky did not change the record, and the Leafs were outshot 36-29 on home ice. Cossa made 27 saves at the other end.
Our view has not changed. Bobrovsky played well enough to keep a regular turn, and Stolarz has played well enough to get more than a backup's share. Who starts Saturday against Montreal is the next test of how flexible Hiller's plan really is.
Special teams flipped the game
Utah's two goals with the man advantage were the difference. The Leafs' penalty kill had been one of the best in the league in October, and it gave up two on Tuesday, including the winner. Toronto did not score on the power play; both Roslovic goals came at even strength.
The Peeke goal is the other special-teams-adjacent decision worth questioning. Hiller explained afterward that Toronto chose not to challenge for goaltender interference because Bobrovsky was outside the blue paint when Hayton made contact, per The Hockey News and The Leafs Nation. That is a defensible reading of the rule. It is also a 2-1 goal in a one-goal game, and a failed challenge costs a minor penalty that a kill this good could absorb. Plenty of coaches would have rolled the dice.
Roslovic and Matthews keep producing
The bright side is the same as it has been for weeks. Roslovic and Matthews connected twice, both at even strength, and the pairing continues to be Toronto's most reliable source of offence. We made the case on Oct. 31 to leave Roslovic with Matthews, and Tuesday was more evidence for it.
The problem is depth. Toronto scored twice in a game where it pushed hard for most of the third period, and neither goal came from anywhere but the top line. That is where John Tavares' return matters.
What's next: Tavares, Montreal and the homestand
Tavares skated in a red non-contact sweater on Tuesday morning, and the Leafs upgraded his lower-body injury to day-to-day, per TSN's Ice Chips report. Hiller said "we still got to do some progressing, but you know, closer," and that the next step is a full practice before any decision on games, per The Hockey News. Tavares has been out since Oct. 15. Sunday's game against New Jersey would be roughly three and a half weeks after the injury, and that is the date most reporters are circling. Bo Groulx, waived on Nov. 2 to make room for Dakota Joshua, cleared waivers unclaimed, per Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman.
The homestand continues with five more games at Scotiabank Arena:
| Date | Opponent | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 7 | Montreal Canadiens | Beat Toronto 3-2 in the Sept. 29 opener |
| Sun., Nov. 8 | New Jersey Devils | Second half of a back-to-back; possible Tavares return |
| Tue., Nov. 10 | Colorado Avalanche | Toronto won 6-3 in Denver on Oct. 10 |
| Thu., Nov. 12 | Minnesota Wild | A day off on either side |
| Sat., Nov. 14 | Edmonton Oilers | Toronto won 7-2 in Edmonton on Oct. 24 |
We set the bar for this stretch in our homestand preview: at least eight points from six games. After Tuesday, that means eight from the next five. It is still doable. It no longer leaves room for another night like this one. Check where Toronto sits in the Atlantic Division standings before Saturday.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the score of the Maple Leafs vs Mammoth game on Nov. 3, 2026?
The Utah Mammoth beat the Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at Scotiabank Arena on Nov. 3, 2026. Nick Schmaltz scored the winner on a power play at 13:12 of the third period, and Jack Roslovic scored both Toronto goals.
Who scored for the Maple Leafs against Utah?
Jack Roslovic scored both Toronto goals, at 10:20 of the second period and 9:05 of the third, the second on a backhand breakaway. Auston Matthews assisted on both goals.
Why did Jim Hiller call out Darren Raddysh?
Raddysh took a cross-checking penalty on Barrett Hayton shortly after Toronto tied the game 2-2, and Utah scored the winner on the ensuing power play. Hiller called it a "stupid penalty" that cost the team, while also describing it as a one-off. Raddysh said he took the blame.
Why didn't the Maple Leafs challenge Andrew Peeke's goal?
Hiller said Toronto chose not to challenge for goaltender interference because Sergei Bobrovsky was outside the crease when Barrett Hayton made contact. The goal gave Utah a 2-1 lead at 13:42 of the second period.
How did Sergei Bobrovsky play against the Mammoth?
Bobrovsky made 33 saves on 36 shots in one of his better games of the season. He took the loss and fell to 3-6-2.
When will John Tavares return for the Maple Leafs?
Tavares skated in a non-contact sweater on Nov. 3 and was upgraded to day-to-day with a lower-body injury he suffered on Oct. 15. Jim Hiller said he needs a full practice first, and the Nov. 8 home game against New Jersey is the most likely target, though nothing is confirmed.
When do the Maple Leafs play next?
Toronto hosts the Montreal Canadiens on Saturday, Nov. 7 at 7 p.m. ET, then the New Jersey Devils on Nov. 8. Both games are at Scotiabank Arena as part of a six-game homestand that runs through Nov. 14.


