Photo: TheAHL, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Darren Raddysh Has Zero Goals in 17 Games. The $68M Bet Needs More
Table of Contents
Darren Raddysh's bad night was not the real problem
Darren Raddysh spent Tuesday night as the reason the Maple Leafs lost. His third-period cross-check on Barrett Hayton handed the Utah Mammoth the power play that produced Nick Schmaltz's winner in a 3-2 loss on Nov. 3, and head coach Jim Hiller called it a "stupid penalty" in his postgame remarks, per TSN. Raddysh owned it: "Took a dumb penalty, so I take the blame for that one."
LeafsLurker's take: the penalty is the least of it. Hiller himself called it "a one-off," and the evidence backs him. Raddysh had six penalty minutes in his first 16 games. What should worry Toronto is not a moment of frustration with his stick. It is that the most productive offensive defenceman in last summer's free-agent class has no goals in 17 games, and the shot that made him worth $68 million has gone quiet.
Seventeen games is not a verdict on an eight-year contract. It is enough to say the Leafs are not getting what they paid for, and that the fix is partly on the coaching staff.
What Toronto paid for
The Leafs acquired Raddysh from the Tampa Bay Lightning in a sign-and-trade on June 19, sending a 2026 fifth-round pick to Tampa after he signed an eight-year deal worth a reported $68 million. That is an $8.5 million cap hit through 2033-34 with trade protection, the highest of any Toronto defenceman. The full numbers are on our Maple Leafs contracts page, and we broke the deal down at the time in our look at the eight-year power-play bet.
The bet was on one season. In 2025-26, Raddysh scored 22 goals and reached 70 points for Tampa, setting a Lightning record for goals by a defenceman. He put 212 shots on net, the most of any Lightning defenceman. General manager John Chayka paid for that version of him: a right-shot defenceman who shoots constantly and runs a power play.
Here is how the two seasons compare, using last season's totals and this season's numbers through 16 games as reported by TSN and Hockey-Reference:
| Season | Team | Goals | Points | Shots per game |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-26 | Tampa Bay | 22 | 70 | 2.9 |
| 2026-27 (16 GP) | Toronto | 0 | 9 | 2.1 |
The drought, in numbers
TSN reported this week that no player in the NHL has put more shots on goal this season without scoring than Raddysh, who had 35 through 16 games. He went without one again on Tuesday. That part is partly luck. A defenceman who shot as often as he did last season will not stay at zero forever, and some of those 35 will start going in.
The part that is not luck is the volume. Raddysh is averaging 2.1 shots per game, down from 2.9 in Tampa. Over a full season that is the difference between roughly 238 shots and 172. For a player whose value is built on getting pucks to the net, a drop of almost a third is the number that matters most.
He is still contributing. Raddysh has nine assists, five of them on the power play, and he is playing about 23 minutes and 40 seconds a night, per Hockey-Reference and ESPN. Nine points in 16 games is respectable for most defencemen. It is not what an $8.5 million defenceman who scored 22 a year ago should look like, and his minus-3 suggests the defensive side is not covering the gap.
Why the shot has dried up
Some of this is context. In Tampa, Raddysh shared the ice with Nikita Kucherov and Brayden Point, two of the league's best passers, and teams had to respect them before they worried about the point. In Toronto, Auston Matthews and William Nylander are the shooters opponents key on, and when the puck runs through them it does not always come back to the blue line. A power play built around Matthews' shot is a good power play. It is not one designed to produce 200 shots for a defenceman.
Some of it is usage. Raddysh opened the season paired with Morgan Rielly, and our position since the preseason has been that he works better with a stay-at-home partner. We argued in the fall that Raddysh needs Chris Tanev, not Rielly, because two puck-movers on one pair end up deferring to each other. October injuries on the back end scrambled the pairs further, and Raddysh has carried heavy minutes with whoever was available.
And some of it is on him. Shots per game is the one number a player controls most directly, and his is down almost a third. A new team, a big contract and a long scoring drought are a recipe for overthinking, and a player trying to justify $8.5 million can start looking for the perfect play instead of the shot that made him. We looked at what his shot can do in our piece on his shot volume and the power play before the season. The case then was that the Leafs needed him to shoot more, not less.
What Hiller should change
Hiller was right to call out the penalty. He should be just as blunt about the shot. Three changes would help:
- Make him the power-play trigger. Run set plays that end with the puck on Raddysh's stick at the top, the way Tampa did. Matthews is dangerous enough to pull a defender without being the shooter every time.
- Give him a defensive partner. When Tanev is healthy, pair them. Raddysh can take more risks shooting when the player beside him is not also pinching.
- Set a shot target. Coaches do this with forwards all the time. Three attempts on net a game is a reasonable floor for a player this offensively minded.
None of these is radical. All of them treat the problem as a fixable one, which it is.
Is it too early to worry?
About the contract, yes. Raddysh has seven more seasons on it, and no one should judge a long-term deal on 17 games. Defencemen who change teams often need a month or two to settle, and his shooting percentage will rise from zero.
About this season, no. Toronto is 8-7-2 with 18 points, on a homestand it needs to win, and the Leafs are relying on two forwards for almost all their offence. Jack Roslovic scored both goals on Tuesday with Matthews assisting on both. A blue line that adds offence would take some weight off that top line. Raddysh is the defenceman who was supposed to provide it.
There is also the trade market. Chayka has said publicly he would make another big move, and our read on his trade plans is that defence is the priority. If Raddysh were scoring like he did in Tampa, the Leafs could shop for a pure shutdown defenceman. If he is not, they need someone who does both, and that player costs far more.
The verdict
The penalty on Tuesday was a bad decision in a bad spot, and Raddysh handled the aftermath the right way. It will be forgotten by Saturday. The missing shot will not, unless he and Hiller fix it.
The Leafs paid $68 million for a defenceman who shoots the puck. For 17 games he has not done that enough. That is the conversation worth having this week, and the Montreal Canadiens on Nov. 7 are a good place to start the answer.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many goals does Darren Raddysh have for the Maple Leafs?
Raddysh has no goals in his first 17 games with Toronto in 2026-27, through the Nov. 3 loss to Utah. Through 16 games he had nine assists, five on the power play, and TSN reported his 35 shots were the most in the NHL by a player without a goal.
What is Darren Raddysh's contract with the Maple Leafs?
Raddysh signed an eight-year contract worth a reported $68 million, an $8.5 million cap hit, before Tampa Bay traded him to Toronto on June 19, 2026 for a fifth-round pick. The deal runs through the 2033-34 season and includes trade protection.
How many goals did Darren Raddysh score last season?
Raddysh scored 22 goals and reached 70 points with the Tampa Bay Lightning in 2025-26, setting a Lightning record for goals by a defenceman. He put 212 shots on net, the most of any Tampa defenceman.
What penalty did Darren Raddysh take against Utah?
Raddysh was called for cross-checking Barrett Hayton in the third period of the Nov. 3 game, shortly after Toronto tied it 2-2. Nick Schmaltz scored the winner on the power play, and Jim Hiller called it a "stupid penalty" while saying it was a one-off.
Who is the highest-paid defenceman on the Maple Leafs?
Darren Raddysh is Toronto's highest-paid defenceman at an $8.5 million cap hit. Morgan Rielly is next at $7.5 million.
How much ice time does Darren Raddysh play?
Raddysh has averaged about 23 minutes and 40 seconds per game through 16 games in 2026-27, according to Hockey-Reference and ESPN. That puts him among Toronto's most-used defencemen.


