Skip to main content
Gavin McKenna Benching: Hiller Got It Right, and the Third Period Proved It

Photo: NHL.com

Opinion

Gavin McKenna Benching: Hiller Got It Right, and the Third Period Proved It

LeafsLurkerNov 8, 20266 min read

Table of Contents

The Gavin McKenna Benching Was the Right Call

The Gavin McKenna benching on Saturday, Nov. 7, was the right decision, and the third period proved it. Jim Hiller sat the 18-year-old for the rest of the second period after a giveaway turned into Chris Kreider's breakaway goal and a 3-0 Montreal lead. McKenna came back in the third and scored less than a minute after William Nylander's power-play goal to make it 3-2. Toronto still lost 4-2, but that sequence is how a coach is supposed to handle a first overall pick.

In October, LeafsLurker said the first McKenna benching was Hiller's mistake. We stand by that. This one is different, and the difference matters for how McKenna's rookie season goes from here.

What Happened Against Montreal

Two Montreal goals came directly off McKenna's mistakes. At 5:56 of the first period, a McKenna giveaway turned into an Alex Newhook pass that caromed off Jake McCabe and Sergei Bobrovsky and into the net. At 12:57 of the second, Kreider read a McKenna pass, picked it off and went in alone. The Leafs Nation counted four giveaways for McKenna on the night.

Hiller did not shorten McKenna's shifts or quietly drop him a line. He sat him. McKenna told reporters afterward, per the Canadian Press, that he expected it: "I knew I was gonna probably sit for that one." He said teammates talked to him in the second intermission and that Hiller pulled him aside. Hiller kept the details private and said only that McKenna has "played really well."

McKenna started the third on the bench and finished it with a goal, collecting a loose puck at the net 55 seconds after Nylander scored. For about five minutes, he had the building back in it. Then Zachary Bolduc scored on the power play at 12:15 and the comeback ended there.

Why October Was Different

The first benching came on Oct. 15 against Buffalo. McKenna played 6:36 and took his last shift with 9:40 left in the second period. He sat the rest of the second, all of the third and overtime while the Sabres came back from 4-2 down to win 5-4. Hiller said afterward, per Daily Faceoff, that a run of penalties had left McKenna sitting and that he then chose not to put him back out. "That's on me," he said.

That was not discipline. It was a coach losing track of a player during a game that got away. The timing also made it worse, three days before McKenna's 10th game, the date that decided whether the first year of his entry-level deal would be used.

Saturday was the opposite. The reason was clear. McKenna knew it. It was limited to one period. Hiller talked to him at the intermission and put him back on the ice. The message was not "we do not trust you." It was "that cannot happen, now go fix it." McKenna did.

The Case Against, and Why It Fails

There is a reasonable argument that you never sit an 18-year-old in a game you are trailing when he is one of your few players who can create a goal from nothing. Toronto was chasing. McKenna's skill is exactly what a team down 3-0 needs. Sitting him for the last seven minutes of the second period meant fewer offensive looks.

That argument would win in February. It does not in November of a rookie season. McKenna is going to play 70-plus NHL games this year. Hiller is not managing one game. He is managing how McKenna plays with the puck for the next decade. Turnovers at the offensive blue line and in the middle of the ice are the habit every elite junior scorer has to unlearn in the NHL, because NHL defenders turn them into breakaways. Better that lesson costs seven minutes now than a playoff game later.

Accountability also has to apply to everybody. Brandon Duhaime's turnover set up Montreal's second goal, according to postgame coverage, and McCabe had a rough night. If Hiller holds the first overall pick to the standard, he has room to hold the veterans to it too.

There is also the room to think about. McKenna said his teammates talked to him at the intermission. That is the leadership group backing the coach's message instead of resenting it, which tells you the benching landed the way Hiller wanted it to. In October, after the Buffalo game, the conversation was about whether the coach had simply forgotten about him. Nobody is asking that this time.

What McKenna Has Shown So Far

None of this changes what McKenna has already shown. He scored twice on the power play in Seattle on Oct. 28 for his first two-goal, three-point NHL game, as we covered in our look at the McKenna-Matthews fit. He has been on the top power-play unit for most of Tavares' absence and now moves to the second unit with Tavares back.

The bigger issue has been deployment. Hiller has moved McKenna up and down the lineup. On Nov. 2 he dropped him to a third line with Colton Sissons and Vinni Lettieri, which we argued gave him the wrong linemates. That is still our view. An 18-year-old who is still learning when to hold the puck and when to move it is better served by linemates who support him on the puck than by a checking centre.

McKenna is on a $1.075 million entry-level contract through 2028-29, per our contracts page. He is the most important long-term asset in the organization. How he is handled this year matters more than any single November result.

What Hiller Has to Do Next

The benching only works if it is followed by trust. That means McKenna plays against New Jersey on Sunday, Nov. 8, in a real role, not on the fourth line and not with his ice time cut because of Saturday. If Hiller sits him again the next night without a new reason, it stops being a lesson and starts being a pattern.

Three things to watch:

  • His linemates. With Tavares on the left wing beside Nick Paul and Nylander, the left-wing spots on the other lines are open. McKenna belongs in the top six.
  • His ice time. McKenna's minutes against the Devils will show whether Hiller has moved on.
  • His puck decisions. The goal came from going to the net. The best version of McKenna this season plays more of that game and gives up fewer blind passes through the middle.

The Bottom Line

Hiller has been criticized on this site and plenty of others for how he has handled McKenna. Saturday was not one of those nights. The benching was clear, short and explained, and the player answered with a goal in the next period. That is development working the way it should.

The Leafs lost, and the loss of Morgan Rielly to a lower-body injury will matter more in the standings than anything McKenna did. But if Toronto's season turns, the McKenna who learns to protect the puck will be a big reason. Saturday's benching was a step in that direction. Now Hiller has to put him right back out against the Devils.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Jim Hiller bench Gavin McKenna?

Hiller sat McKenna for the rest of the second period on Nov. 7 after McKenna's pass was intercepted by Montreal's Chris Kreider, who scored on a breakaway at 12:57 to make it 3-0. An earlier McKenna giveaway led to Montreal's first goal.

Did Gavin McKenna score after being benched?

Yes. McKenna returned in the third period and scored 55 seconds after William Nylander's power-play goal, cutting Montreal's lead to 3-2. The Canadiens won 4-2.

What did Gavin McKenna say about being benched?

McKenna told reporters, per the Canadian Press, that he knew he was probably going to sit after the turnover. He said teammates talked to him at the second intermission and that Hiller pulled him aside.

Has Gavin McKenna been benched before?

Yes. On Oct. 15 against Buffalo, McKenna played 6:36 and sat from 9:40 left in the second period through overtime of a 5-4 loss. Hiller said afterward that it was not intentional and took the blame.

How old is Gavin McKenna?

McKenna was born on Dec. 20, 2007, which makes him 18. Toronto drafted him first overall in 2026.

What is Gavin McKenna's contract?

McKenna is on a three-year entry-level contract with a $1.075 million cap hit that runs through 2028-29. He passed the nine-game mark in October, so the first year of the deal has been used.

Share this article