Skip to main content
Gavin McKenna Third Line: Hiller's New Mix Gives Him the Wrong Linemates

Photo: NHL.com

Opinion

Gavin McKenna Third Line: Hiller's New Mix Gives Him the Wrong Linemates

LeafsLurkerNov 3, 20267 min read

Table of Contents

The Gavin McKenna third line is back for Utah

Gavin McKenna is back on the Maple Leafs' third line. At practice on Monday, Nov. 2, head coach Jim Hiller reshuffled his forwards ahead of Tuesday's home game against the Utah Mammoth: Easton Cowan returned to the top line with Auston Matthews and Jack Roslovic, Dakota Joshua moved up beside Nick Paul and William Nylander, and McKenna landed with Colton Sissons and Vinni Lettieri, per TSN and The Leafs Nation.

The Gavin McKenna third line is not new. Hiller tried it in early October and it worked. What has changed is who he is playing with. LeafsLurker's take: the problem with Monday's lineup is not the line number beside McKenna's name. It is the linemates. Putting the first overall pick with a fourth-line centre and a call-up who has one NHL goal this season asks an 18-year-old to drive a line on his own at even strength, which is the part of his game that still needs support.

The new Maple Leafs lines

Here is how the forwards lined up at Monday's practice. The defence pairs were unchanged from the 4-2 win in Vancouver on Oct. 31, and Sergei Bobrovsky will start in goal:

LineLeft wingCentreRight wing
FirstEaston CowanAuston MatthewsJack Roslovic
SecondDakota JoshuaNick PaulWilliam Nylander
ThirdGavin McKennaColton SissonsVinni Lettieri
FourthBrandon DuhaimeTeddy BluegerZack MacEwen

Some of the logic is easy to follow. With John Tavares still out, Paul is playing second-line centre, and Joshua gives that line size and a net-front presence that Nylander's game benefits from. Cowan has been one of Matthews' most effective wingers this season, and Hiller has been effusive about him, saying after a three-point night in Columbus that he could not say enough good things about the sophomore. The fourth line of Duhaime, Blueger and MacEwen stayed together after MacEwen and Blueger both scored in Vancouver.

The third line is where it falls apart. Sissons is a defensive centre on a $4.25 million deal who has five points this season, per MarkerZone. Lettieri is a 31-year-old on a one-year, $850,000 two-way contract who was recalled from the Marlies on Oct. 19 and has one goal in seven games. Neither is the kind of player who creates easy chances for a young winger.

What McKenna has done through 16 games

McKenna has five goals and six assists for 11 points in 16 games, with a minus-6 rating and about 13:43 of ice time a night, per Hockey-Reference and Elite Prospects. For an 18-year-old in his first month of pro hockey, that is a strong line. Here is where he sits among Toronto's forwards on the numbers that matter for this debate:

MeasureMcKennaContext
Points11 in 16 gamesOn pace for about 56 over 82
Goals5Two came on the power play in Seattle on Oct. 28
Plus-minusMinus-6The even-strength concern
Ice timeAbout 13:43 a gameLow for a top-six scorer

The split inside those numbers is the whole story. McKenna has been dangerous on the power play, where he has the puck on his stick and space to make plays. At five-on-five he has been on the ice for more goals against than for. That is normal for a teenager, and it is exactly why linemates matter. A rookie who is still learning NHL defensive reads needs a centre who can cover for him and a winger who can retrieve pucks and get them back to him.

The October version worked

The first time Hiller moved McKenna down, for the Oct. 8 game in Vegas, the rookie picked up an assist as Toronto built a 3-0 first-period lead in what became a 4-3 shootout loss. We wrote then that the third-line move was working and Hiller should leave it alone. The difference was the support. That version gave McKenna a centre who could carry the puck and defensive cover behind him. Monday's version gives him the defensive cover and nothing else.

Why the top-line stint ended so fast

Hiller promoted McKenna to Matthews' line on Oct. 28 in Seattle. He told reporters that day that he hoped McKenna would feel comfortable playing with Matthews and that by now he had played enough in the league to simply go play his game, per Maple Leafs Hot Stove. McKenna scored twice on the power play that night, and we wrote about what that game meant for the Matthews fit.

The even-strength results with Matthews were less convincing, and McKenna was held off the scoresheet in Vancouver. Cowan, meanwhile, had a rough end to the road trip but had been productive with Matthews earlier in October. Hiller chose the proven combination. That is a reasonable call on its own. The issue is what it did to McKenna's minutes and linemates as a side effect.

The fix: give him a playmaker or give him Joshua back

There are two simple ways to make the third line make sense without undoing the top six.

Option one: swap Lettieri for a right winger who can carry the puck. Toronto's depth here is thin with Kirill Marchenko out week-to-week, but MacEwen scored in Vancouver and plays a direct, north-south game that would at least get pucks deep and back to McKenna. Lettieri, who had 26 points in 23 playoff games for the Calder Cup-winning Marlies last spring, could slot onto the fourth line where his minutes would be lighter.

Option two: put Joshua back with McKenna and Sissons. Hiller himself has praised a Sissons, Joshua and McKenna line as effective. Joshua's size and forechecking are the kind of support McKenna needs. The cost is Nylander's line losing its new net-front presence, which is a smaller loss than stalling the development of the team's best young forward.

Either choice is better than asking McKenna to carry a line built for defence. And neither changes the most important thing: McKenna should stay on the first power-play unit regardless of where he plays at five-on-five. We made that case in keeping him on PP1 when Tavares returns, and the Seattle game proved it.

What Tavares' return changes

The lineup is about to change again. Tavares skated on his own before practice on Monday and will not play against Utah, but reports point to a return during the homestand, possibly as soon as Nov. 8 against New Jersey. When he comes back, Paul likely shifts back to third-line centre, which immediately gives McKenna a better centre than Monday's arrangement.

That points to the most natural landing spot for the rookie over the rest of November: a third line of McKenna, Paul and Joshua, with real two-way support and a centre who can make plays. It is the line Hiller should be building toward. Until then, the coach has a week of practice days on this homestand to find a better short-term mix than Sissons and Lettieri.

The bigger picture for the Leafs

McKenna's development is the most important long-term story in Toronto this season. The Leafs drafted him first overall in June, and his three-year entry-level deal carries a $1,075,000 cap hit through 2028-29, as listed on our contracts page. Every month he spends in a role that suits him makes the Leafs better, now and when Matthews' deal comes up after 2027-28.

None of this means Hiller is wrong to make McKenna earn top-line minutes. Rookies get moved around, and a third-line spot is not a demotion when the line is built properly. But the Leafs are 8-6-2 and need goals from their skill players at even strength. Putting their most creative young forward in a spot where the puck rarely gets to him is the wrong way to get them. You can follow McKenna's numbers on our players page.

Frequently Asked Questions

What line is Gavin McKenna on for the Maple Leafs?

At practice on Nov. 2, 2026, Jim Hiller moved McKenna to the third line with Colton Sissons and Vinni Lettieri for the Nov. 3 home game against Utah. Easton Cowan replaced him on the top line with Auston Matthews and Jack Roslovic. McKenna had been moved onto Matthews' line on Oct. 28 in Seattle.

How many points does Gavin McKenna have this season?

Through 16 games of 2026-27, McKenna has five goals and six assists for 11 points with a minus-6 rating. He averages roughly 13:43 of ice time per game. That puts him on pace for about 56 points over 82 games.

Why was Gavin McKenna moved off Auston Matthews' line?

Hiller reunited Cowan with Matthews and Roslovic after the western road trip and moved Dakota Joshua to the second line for size beside Nick Paul and William Nylander. McKenna scored twice on the power play in his first game with Matthews on Oct. 28, but the even-strength results were less convincing and he was held off the scoresheet in Vancouver on Oct. 31.

Who is Vinni Lettieri?

Vinni Lettieri is a 31-year-old forward on a one-year, $850,000 two-way contract with Toronto for 2026-27. He had 26 points in 23 playoff games for the Toronto Marlies during their 2026 Calder Cup run. The Leafs recalled him on Oct. 19, and he has one goal in seven NHL games.

Is Gavin McKenna still on the Leafs' power play?

McKenna has been one of Toronto's most dangerous power-play options, scoring twice with the man advantage in Seattle on Oct. 28. Monday's line change affected his five-on-five role. LeafsLurker's view is that he should stay on the first unit regardless of his even-strength line.

How much is Gavin McKenna's contract?

McKenna, the first overall pick in the 2026 NHL Draft, is on a three-year entry-level contract with a $1,075,000 cap hit that runs through 2028-29. He will be a restricted free agent when it expires. Performance bonuses can add to his total pay.

Share this article