Skip to main content
Maple Leafs Playoff Chances: The Math After an 8-10-2 Start

Photo: NHL.com

Analysis

Maple Leafs Playoff Chances: The Math After an 8-10-2 Start

LeafsLurkerNov 12, 20266 min read

Table of Contents

Maple Leafs Playoff Chances: Where Things Stand

The Maple Leafs' playoff chances took a real hit this month. Toronto is 8-10-2 with 18 points after 20 games, has lost four straight and six of seven, and sat second-last in the Atlantic Division after the 6-3 loss to Colorado on Nov. 10, per The Canadian Press. The AP had the Leafs 10th in the Eastern Conference. With 64 games left in the NHL's first 84-game season since 1993-94, the hole is not fatal. But it is deep enough that the math deserves a hard look.

This piece does the arithmetic. No projections from a black-box model, just points, games and the record Toronto has to post from here. Our short answer: the Leafs need to play at roughly a 98-point pace for the rest of the season. They have done that before. They are not doing it now.

The Playoff Line in Recent Seasons

Start with the target. In the two most recent 82-game seasons before last year, the second Eastern Conference wild card finished with 91 points both times: the Washington Capitals in 2023-24 and the Montreal Canadiens in 2024-25. Last season the East race ran deep into April, with Columbus holding the second wild card at 88 points on April 2 with games still to play, per NHL.com.

The 2026-27 schedule adds two games per team, so the line should move up a little. Scaling 91 points from 82 games to 84 gives about 93. That's the working number for this analysis. It could be lower if the East is weak, or a couple of points higher if the middle of the conference is crowded.

The Points Math

Here's what Toronto needs to reach different targets, with 64 games left:

TargetPoints neededPoints per gamePoints % needed
90 points721.13.563
93 points751.17.586
96 points781.22.609

For comparison, Toronto's current points percentage is .450 (18 of a possible 40). At that pace the Leafs would finish with about 76 points, short of last season's 78-point total that cost Craig Berube his job.

The middle row is the one that matters. A .586 points percentage over a full 84-game season is about 98 points. A record like 36-25-3 the rest of the way would get Toronto to 93. That's not a fantasy for a team with Auston Matthews and William Nylander. The Leafs won the Atlantic with 108 points in 2024-25. But it requires something close to a different team than the one that has played the last three weeks.

Why the Last Seven Games Matter So Much

The Leafs were a playoff-pace team in October. The slide since Kirill Marchenko was hurt in Calgary on Oct. 26 is what turned a manageable start into a problem.

DateOpponentResult
Oct. 26Calgary FlamesLost 5-2
Oct. 28Seattle KrakenLost 5-4
Oct. 31Vancouver CanucksWon 4-2
Nov. 3Utah MammothLost 3-2
Nov. 7Montreal CanadiensLost 4-2
Nov. 8New Jersey DevilsLost 4-0
Nov. 10Colorado AvalancheLost 6-3

One win in seven games. Toronto scored seven goals in the four November losses and allowed 17. Every one of those games cost ground that now has to be made up.

The good news is that most of what caused the slide is temporary. Marchenko is week-to-week. Morgan Rielly has been day-to-day since leaving the Nov. 7 game in Montreal. Colton Sissons, Nick Blankenburg and Marshall Rifai are all out, and Zack MacEwen hurt his wrist against Colorado. A healthy lineup should play closer to the October version than the November one.

What Has to Change to Improve the Maple Leafs' Playoff Chances

Three things, in order of importance:

  • Five-on-five scoring. Reports after the Nov. 8 shutout had the Leafs as the NHL's lowest-scoring team at five-on-five since Marchenko went down. Our case that Chayka needs a forward now is built on that.
  • Fewer self-inflicted goals. Head coach Jim Hiller said after the Colorado loss that the team keeps making strings of bad decisions, and that veteran players can't keep doing it, per TSN. He said the record is "deserved."
  • Goaltending. Sergei Bobrovsky and Anthony Stolarz have both had stretches where they kept Toronto in games and stretches where they didn't. A playoff push at a .586 clip almost always comes with above-average goaltending.

The defensive side has already prompted lineup changes. Hiller moved Chris Tanev to the third pair at practice on Nov. 11, and we explain why the Tanev move makes sense.

What the Pace Looks Like in Practice

Big targets are easier to understand in smaller pieces. Hitting 75 points in 64 games works out to roughly 12 points in every 10-game stretch the rest of the way. Here is what that looks like as a running checkpoint, assuming Toronto stays exactly on the 93-point pace.

Games playedPoints neededExample record
303013-13-4 (a 5-3-2 run)
42 (halfway)44Roughly 19-17-6
6065Roughly 30-25-5
8493Roughly 44-35-5

The first row is the hard one. Getting from 18 points to about 30 by the 30-game mark means something like 5-3-2 over the next 10 games, with a depleted lineup. Toronto has one win in its last seven.

There is a hopeful precedent. The 2019-20 Leafs were 9-10-4 when they changed coaches in November and recovered to reach the 2020 qualifying round. That team got there on talent once it found its game. This one has the talent at the top. The question is whether it has enough depth to carry the load until the injured players return.

The Atlantic Picture

The standings are crowded, and they move nightly. Rather than lock in a ranking that will be stale by the weekend, check the live table on our standings page. Two structural points matter more than any single night's order.

First, the 84-game schedule adds divisional games. That means more four-point nights against the teams Toronto is chasing, which helps a team that gets hot and hurts one that doesn't. Second, the wild cards are pooled across the Atlantic and Metropolitan divisions. Toronto doesn't have to pass every Atlantic rival, only enough Eastern teams to get to eighth.

We wrote on Nov. 2 that the Leafs' 18 points were weaker than they looked. They have played four more games since then and still have 18 points.

What's Next: The Wild and a December Checkpoint

The next test is Thursday night at home against the Minnesota Wild, one of the best teams in the Western Conference. Our Maple Leafs vs. Wild preview has the matchup. A win would stop the bleeding. A fifth straight loss would push the required pace above .590 for the remaining 63 games.

Our checkpoint is the 30-game mark. If Toronto is at or near .500 in points percentage by then, with Marchenko and Rielly back, the math is very much alive. If the Leafs are still around .450, GM John Chayka will face a different question: whether to buy for a push or protect the long-term plan built around Gavin McKenna. That's a decision for December. For now, the job is simpler. Win hockey games.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the Maple Leafs make the playoffs in 2026-27?

It is still possible but the Leafs have work to do. At 8-10-2 with 18 points after 20 games, Toronto needs roughly 75 points in its final 64 games to reach about 93, a typical second wild-card total adjusted for the 84-game schedule. That requires a .586 points percentage, compared with .450 so far.

How many points does it take to make the NHL playoffs?

The second Eastern Conference wild card finished with 91 points in both 2023-24 (Washington) and 2024-25 (Montreal) in 82-game seasons. With the 2026-27 season expanded to 84 games, a comparable line would be about 93 points. The exact cutoff varies with how competitive the conference is.

How many games are in the 2026-27 NHL season?

The 2026-27 NHL regular season has 84 games per team, the first time since 1993-94 that teams have played more than 82. The season opened Sept. 29, 2026 and ends April 10, 2027. The extra games are against divisional opponents.

What is the Maple Leafs' record this season?

The Maple Leafs were 8-10-2 with 18 points after 20 games, heading into their Nov. 12, 2026 home game against the Minnesota Wild. They had lost four straight and six of their previous seven. The Canadian Press had them second-last in the Atlantic Division.

Did the Maple Leafs make the playoffs last season?

No. The Leafs finished 2025-26 at 32-36-14 with 78 points and were eliminated from playoff contention on April 2, 2026, their first missed postseason since 2015-16. Coach Craig Berube was fired on May 13, 2026, and Jim Hiller was hired on June 17.

When is Kirill Marchenko coming back from injury?

Kirill Marchenko has been out since suffering a lower-body injury against Calgary on Oct. 26, 2026, and has been listed week-to-week. Darren Dreger reported in early November that he was about two weeks away, and some injury trackers have listed Nov. 17 as an estimated return. The Leafs have not confirmed a date.

Share this article