
Photo: NHL.com
Roman Josi Trade: Leafs Should Only Do It If Rielly Goes to Nashville
Table of Contents
The Roman Josi Trade Talk, in Plain Terms
The Roman Josi trade chatter has landed on the Maple Leafs. Over the past week, several reports have linked Toronto to the Nashville Predators captain, and one, attributed to Shawn Sinclair, described the clubs as having talked over the past two weeks while both try to reshape their defence. No trade has been announced. None of the top national insiders has reported that a deal is close, and Josi has a no-movement clause that means nothing happens without his say-so.
LeafsLurker's position: Josi is the right kind of target for John Chayka, a genuine top-pair defenceman rather than another depth body. But the version of this deal that keeps getting floated, a first-round pick plus Ben Danford for a 36-year-old with $9 million owed through next season, is the wrong one. Toronto should do it only if Morgan Rielly's contract goes the other way and the Colorado first stays home.
Who Roman Josi Is in 2026
Josi is a left-shot defenceman from Switzerland, born June 1, 1990, which makes him 36. He won the Norris Trophy in 2020 and has worn the Predators' "C" since 2017. He is still productive. NHL.com's recap of Nashville's 4-1 win over Carolina on Nov. 3 had him with a goal and an assist, and season stat tables put him at 17 points, two goals and 15 assists, through his first 15 games. Last season he had 55 points, 13 goals and 42 assists, in 68 games while averaging just under 25 minutes a night.
That is still a first-pair offensive defenceman. It is also a player whose minus-15 last season reflects a team that was going nowhere, and whose best years were five or six seasons ago. The Predators were 6-4-5 after the Carolina win, which is the kind of start that makes a rebuilding front office listen. Nashville GM Chris MacFarland has already turned over a lot of the roster, and Pierre LeBrun has previously reported that a Josi move could come if Nashville falls well out of the race.
The Contract Toronto Would Be Taking On
Josi signed an eight-year, $72.5 million extension in October 2019. It carries a cap hit of about $9.06 million and runs through 2027-28. Reports differ on one detail: some say the no-movement clause covers the full term, others that it covers the first seven years and lapses for the final season. Either way, he controls where he goes this season.
Here is how Josi would slot against the Leafs' current defence, using the figures on our Leafs contracts page.
| Defenceman | Shot | Cap hit | Signed through | Clause |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roman Josi (Nashville) | Left | $9.06 million | 2027-28 | NMC |
| Darren Raddysh | Right | $8.5 million | 2033-34 | NMC |
| Morgan Rielly | Left | $7.5 million | 2029-30 | NMC |
| Chris Tanev | Right | $4.5 million | 2029-30 | NMC |
| Jake McCabe | Left | $4.49 million | 2029-30 | 16-team no-trade list |
| Oliver Ekman-Larsson | Left | $3.5 million | 2027-28 | Modified no-trade |
| Troy Stecher | Right | $1.35 million | 2027-28 | None |
Josi would become the highest-paid defenceman in Toronto. With the 2026-27 cap at $104 million and the Leafs already working in long-term injured reserve territory, there is no way to add $9 million without sending substantial salary back. That is not a detail. It is the whole deal.
The Price Being Floated Is Too High
One rumour outlet has suggested Nashville could ask for Toronto's 2027 first-round pick from Colorado plus defence prospects Ben Danford and Alexander Bilecki, according to that report. That is speculation, not a reported offer, but it is a useful marker for what a seller would want.
Look at what that pick is. Toronto's own 2027 first already belongs to Boston from the Brandon Carlo trade, and its 2028 first is owed to Philadelphia. The Colorado pick, acquired in the Nicolas Roy trade, is the only first-rounder the Leafs hold in the next two drafts, as our draft picks tracker shows. It is also top-10 protected, which makes it awkward to move. Danford, the 31st pick in 2024, is a right-shot defenceman in his first full AHL season with the Marlies and one of the few blue-line prospects in the system with a real NHL projection.
Spending both on a defenceman who turns 37 next June, and who would eat up most of Toronto's cap flexibility for next season too, is a bad trade even if Josi plays well. It would be the kind of deal that wins headlines in November and costs the club its only premium future assets.
The Version Toronto Should Want
The deal that makes sense starts with Rielly. He is 32, carries $7.5 million through 2029-30 and has a no-movement clause of his own, so he would have to agree to go. If he does, a Rielly-for-Josi framework does three things at once.
- Cap: It nets out at roughly $1.5 million added this season and next, instead of $9 million.
- Term: It swaps two more seasons of Rielly's contract beyond 2027-28 for a deal that ends in 2028, which opens real space for the summer of 2028.
- Assets: It means the sweetener can be a second-round pick or a mid-tier prospect, not the Colorado first or Danford.
Would Nashville want Rielly's term? Probably not at first. But the Predators are the ones with a 36-year-old captain on an expiring-type deal and a direction that points toward younger players. If MacFarland wants a first-round pick for Josi, he can ask a team with more cap room. Toronto's advantage is that it can take on salary in the short term in a way many contenders cannot, but only by sending some back.
If Rielly will not waive, the next option is a package built around Ekman-Larsson's $3.5 million and McCabe's $4.49 million. Both have trade protection, and McCabe's 16-team no-trade list makes him harder to move to a specific destination. That route costs the Leafs more depth than it should, and it is where Chayka should be most willing to walk away.
Is Josi Even the Right Fix?
It is fair to ask whether a defenceman is the answer at all. Toronto was 8-7-2 heading into the weekend. Through 17 games, its problems have been goaltending and penalties as much as defence, with Sergei Bobrovsky struggling and the Leafs taking more minors than almost any team in the league. Josi will not fix either. And as we argued about Nashville's other defenceman on the market, Nic Hague, the Leafs should not take on a Predators contract just because Nashville is selling.
The case for Josi is different from the case against Hague. Hague would be a mid-pair player on a long deal. Josi is still a difference-maker who would upgrade Toronto's top four and its second power-play unit immediately. That is the profile we outlined in our look at who actually counts as a difference-maker on defence, and Josi fits it in a way few available defencemen do.
What Chayka Has Said and What to Watch
Chayka has said publicly that he is open to another major trade, which we covered when he discussed his trade plans in late October. Insiders have reported for weeks that Toronto wants a top-four defenceman rather than a depth piece. Jeff Marek has also floated Josi as a fit for Toronto. None of that is the same as a deal being close.
Three things will tell you whether this is real. First, whether a TSN or Sportsnet insider confirms talks, rather than rumour sites. Second, whether Nashville drifts out of the race, because LeBrun's reporting suggested that is the trigger. Third, whether Josi signals he would waive for Toronto. Until all three move, treat this as smoke.
If it does turn real, Toronto should be clear about its line. Josi for Rielly plus a reasonable add, yes. Josi for the Colorado first and Danford, no. The Leafs need a defenceman. They do not need to mortgage the one first-round pick they have left to get a 36-year-old one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the Maple Leafs trading for Roman Josi?
No trade has been announced. Several reports in early November 2026 linked Toronto to the Nashville captain, including one describing talks between the clubs, but no top national insider has reported a deal as close. Josi's no-movement clause means he would have to approve any trade.
How much is Roman Josi's contract?
Josi signed an eight-year, $72.5 million extension with Nashville in October 2019. It carries a cap hit of about $9.06 million and runs through the 2027-28 season.
Does Roman Josi have a no-movement clause?
Yes. Josi's contract includes a no-movement clause, so he controls whether he can be traded. Reports differ on whether it covers all eight years or lapses for the final season, 2027-28.
How old is Roman Josi?
Josi was born on June 1, 1990, so he is 36 during the 2026-27 season. He will turn 37 before his contract's final season, 2027-28.
How many points does Roman Josi have this season?
Through his first 15 games of 2026-27, season stat tables had Josi with 17 points on two goals and 15 assists, including a goal and an assist in a 4-1 win over Carolina on Nov. 3. Last season he had 55 points in 68 games.
Has Roman Josi won the Norris Trophy?
Yes. Josi won the Norris Trophy as the NHL's top defenceman in 2020. He has been Nashville's captain since 2017.
What first-round picks do the Maple Leafs have?
Toronto's own 2027 first-round pick is owed to Boston and its 2028 first to Philadelphia. The Leafs hold Colorado's 2027 first, top-10 protected, from the Nicolas Roy trade in March 2026.


