Photo: Jenn G from Seattle, WA, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)
Nic Hague Trade Talk: The Maple Leafs Should Hang Up on Nashville
Table of Contents
The Nic Hague trade talk, and why Toronto should pass
The Nic Hague trade chatter started with one line from TSN's Darren Dreger in late October: "I've heard Nic Hague's name is out there." Since then, the 6-foot-6 Nashville Predators defenceman has been attached to the Maple Leafs in the usual way, because Toronto is the team everyone knows is shopping for a defenceman. No deal has been reported, and there is no confirmed sign that the Leafs have even asked about him.
LeafsLurker's position: they should not. Hague is a big, left-shot, defence-first player, which sounds like what Toronto has been looking for. But his contract, his start and his fit on the Leafs' depth chart all point the same way. He would cost real assets and real cap space to fill a role Toronto already has covered.
What has actually been reported
It is worth being precise, because a lot of what circulates about Toronto's defence search is speculation.
- Dreger, late October: Hague's name is "out there," meaning Nashville is willing to listen. Dreger did not report a specific team, a price or that talks were advanced.
- Other outlets: Several have since linked Hague to the Leafs because of Toronto's well-known search for a defenceman, not because of any reported conversation between the clubs.
- Toronto's stated target: Insiders have reported for weeks that John Chayka wants a defenceman who moves the needle, not a depth piece. Dreger said in mid-October that the Leafs were not interested in adding a depth defenceman.
Chayka himself has said he is open to another big swing before the deadline, which we covered when he discussed his trade plans in late October. The question is not whether Toronto will make a move. It is whether Hague is the right one.
The contract is the first problem
Hague was traded from Vegas to Nashville on June 30, 2025, in the deal that sent Colton Sissons and Jeremy Lauzon to the Golden Knights. He immediately signed a four-year, $22 million extension with the Predators. That works out to a $5.5 million cap hit through 2028-29. Reports also say a six-team no-trade list kicks in next season.
Here is how that number compares with what Toronto already pays its defence, using the figures on our Leafs contracts page:
| Defenceman | Shot | Cap hit | Signed through |
|---|---|---|---|
| Darren Raddysh | Right | $8.5 million | 2033-34 |
| Morgan Rielly | Left | $7.5 million | 2029-30 |
| Nic Hague (Nashville) | Left | $5.5 million | 2028-29 |
| Chris Tanev | Right | $4.5 million | 2029-30 |
| Jake McCabe | Left | $4.49 million | 2029-30 |
| Oliver Ekman-Larsson | Left | $3.5 million | 2027-28 |
| Troy Stecher | Right | $1.35 million | 2027-28 |
Hague would be Toronto's third-highest-paid defenceman, ahead of both McCabe and Tanev, for three more seasons after this one. With the 2026-27 cap at $104 million and the Leafs already carrying a lot of long-term money on the blue line, adding $5.5 million would almost certainly mean sending salary back to Nashville. That makes the deal more complicated and more expensive in roster terms, not just in picks or prospects.
The start is the second problem
Hague has one assist in 13 games this season with a minus-7 rating, 17 penalty minutes and 10 shots on goal, averaging 16:34 a night, according to CBS Sports and ESPN. RotoWire projects him in a bottom-four defensive role. Last season he had 15 points in 62 games and missed three separate stretches with injuries, per RotoWire.
Points are not the main job for a player like Hague, and plus-minus is a blunt stat. But the ice time is telling. A defenceman playing 16 and a half minutes a night is not being used as a top-pair or even a clear top-four option by his own coach. Toronto would be paying top-four money for a player Nashville is using as a third-pair defender.
The fit is the third problem
Look at Toronto's defence pairs from Wednesday's practice: McCabe with Raddysh, Rielly with Tanev, and Ekman-Larsson with Stecher. Three left-shot defencemen, three right-shot defencemen. Hague is a left shot.
That means one of two things would happen if he arrived. Either he replaces Ekman-Larsson on the third pair, which makes him an expensive upgrade on a $3.5 million veteran, or he moves into the top four and pushes McCabe or Rielly down. Neither of those is the fix the Leafs need. Their weak spot has been on the right side when Tanev is hurt, and their overall issue is getting the puck out of their own end. Hague is not known as a puck-mover.
Head coach Jim Hiller said on Wednesday, per The Leafs Nation, that "we're spending too much time in our own zone." A big, physical defender who struggles to move the puck makes a team better at defending in its own zone. It does not get the team out of it faster.
Better options are out there
This is not an argument for standing still. Toronto is 8-7-2 with 18 points, its goals against have been a problem all season and its defence has been thin whenever injuries hit. The Leafs should add a defenceman. They should just add the right one.
We argued in October that Calgary's Zach Whitecloud is a better match: a right shot, a defence-first player and a cheaper contract. The bigger targets, such as Detroit's Simon Edvinsson, remain more complicated, and we laid out why Toronto cannot sit out that race. Either one addresses the actual need better than Hague does.
There is also the question of what Toronto would give up. Reports have said Toronto took Easton Cowan off the table, and Gavin McKenna obviously is not going anywhere. The Leafs' tradeable pieces are their future picks, which you can see on our draft picks page, plus prospects below the top tier. Those assets are finite. Spending them on a $5.5 million third-pair defender leaves less for the move that actually changes the team.
The case for Hague, and why it falls short
To be fair to the idea, there is a version of this that makes some sense. Hague is 27, he is huge, he has playoff experience from his Vegas years, and his contract is not an anchor in a $104 million cap world. If Nashville is looking to dump salary and would take back Ekman-Larsson's $3.5 million contract plus a mid-round pick, the cost drops enough to be interesting.
But that is a best-case scenario, and Nashville has no reason to accept it. Teams do not sell four-year contracts at a discount in November unless they are desperate, and the Predators have not given any public sign of that. In any realistic version of the trade, Toronto pays more than Hague is worth to them.
What's next
Expect Hague's name to keep coming up, because every available defenceman gets linked to Toronto. Watch for whether any insider reports actual talks between the clubs, which has not happened yet. And watch where Chayka's attention goes: the Leafs' GM has been patient so far, and we have argued that waiting is right, but not for long.
The Leafs need a defenceman who helps them get out of their own end. Nic Hague is a fine player on the wrong contract for the wrong role. Chayka should make his big swing, and he should make it for someone else.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Nic Hague being traded?
TSN's Darren Dreger said in late October 2026 that he had heard Nic Hague's name is 'out there,' meaning Nashville is willing to listen. No trade has been reported, and no insider has reported talks with a specific team.
What is Nic Hague's contract?
Hague signed a four-year, $22 million extension with Nashville on June 30, 2025, after being acquired from Vegas. It carries a $5.5 million cap hit through the 2028-29 season, and reports say a six-team no-trade list starts next season.
How is Nic Hague playing this season?
Through about Nov. 3, Hague had one assist in 13 games with a minus-7 rating, 17 penalty minutes and 10 shots, averaging 16:34 of ice time, according to CBS Sports and ESPN. Last season he had 15 points in 62 games.
Are the Maple Leafs interested in Nic Hague?
Hague has been linked to Toronto by several outlets because the Leafs are known to be searching for a defenceman, but no reported conversation between the teams has surfaced. Insiders have said John Chayka wants an impact defenceman rather than a depth piece.
How did Nic Hague end up in Nashville?
Vegas traded Hague to Nashville on June 30, 2025, in exchange for Colton Sissons and Jeremy Lauzon. Hague then signed his four-year extension with the Predators.
How tall is Nic Hague?
Hague is listed at 6-foot-6 and shoots left. Vegas drafted him in the second round, 34th overall, in 2017 out of the OHL's Mississauga Steelheads.
Who are the Maple Leafs' defence trade targets?
Players linked to Toronto this season include Calgary's Zach Whitecloud, Detroit's Simon Edvinsson and Nashville's Nic Hague. None of those links has produced a reported deal as of early November 2026.


