Skip to main content
Colorado First-Round Pick: MacKinnon, Makar Injuries and the Leafs

Photo: NHL.com

Draft

Colorado First-Round Pick: MacKinnon, Makar Injuries and the Leafs

LeafsLurkerNov 14, 20267 min read

Table of Contents

Why Avalanche Injuries Matter in Toronto

Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar both left Colorado's 4-3 overtime loss in Ottawa on Nov. 12 with lower-body injuries, and neither returned. For most of the league, that is an Avalanche problem. In Toronto it is also a draft story, because the Maple Leafs own the Colorado first-round pick in the 2027 draft, the most important trade chip John Chayka has as he hunts for a defenceman.

As of Saturday morning, Colorado had not given a diagnosis or timeline for either player. Coach Jared Bednar said after the game that he had no update, and both players were travelling with the team to Montreal for Saturday's game against the Canadiens, with their status uncertain, per NHL.com and TSN. The Avalanche recalled forward Gavin Brindley from the AHL on Friday.

The injuries may turn out to be minor. But they are a useful moment to lay out exactly what Toronto owns, what the protection on it means, and why the pick's value is tied to how Colorado's season goes from here.

What Happened in Ottawa

Both stars went down in the second period. Reports from the game described MacKinnon grabbing his right side after attempting a reverse hit on Senators defenceman Artem Zub. Makar's exit came days after he left practice on Nov. 8 for what the team called precautionary reasons.

Colorado still nearly won. Down 2-0, the Avalanche scored three straight goals through Artturi Lehkonen, Parker Kelly and Gabriel Landeskog to lead in the third, before Drake Batherson tied it with 3:56 left in regulation and Shane Pinto scored his second of the night 2:08 into overtime, per NHL.com. The loss left Colorado 11-6-3, third in the Central Division, with points in four straight games.

Toronto knows the Avalanche well this month. Colorado beat the Leafs 6-3 at Scotiabank Arena on Nov. 10, with Landeskog scoring twice. Our recap of that game has the details of a night when Toronto could not keep up with Colorado's top players.

What the Leafs Own: The Colorado First-Round Pick, Explained

Toronto acquired the Colorado first-round pick in the Nicolas Roy trade on March 5, 2026. It comes with a top-10 protection, per the Leafs' release at the time and the team's draft picks page. The table below sets out how it works.

ScenarioWhere the pick landsWhat Toronto gets
Colorado makes the playoffs or finishes mid-pack11th or laterColorado's 2027 first-round pick
Colorado collapsesTop 10Colorado's unprotected 2028 first instead
Knock-on effect if it rolls to 2028Not applicableNashville, which holds that 2028 pick, gets Colorado's 2029 first

The 2028 wrinkle matters. Colorado had already traded its 2028 first to Calgary in the Nazem Kadri deal on March 6, 2026, and that pick has since moved through New Jersey to Nashville, per DNVR and Colorado Hockey Now. If Toronto's pick rolls over, Nashville is compensated with Colorado's 2029 first.

Just as important is what Toronto does not own. The Leafs' own 2027 first goes to Boston from the Brandon Carlo trade, because the 2026 pick was protected and became Gavin McKenna. Their own 2028 first is owed to Philadelphia from the Scott Laughton trade. Colorado's pick is the only first-rounder Toronto holds in the next two drafts.

DraftToronto's own firstExtra first held
2027Traded to Boston (Carlo trade)Colorado's, top-10 protected
2028Traded to Philadelphia (Laughton trade)None, unless Colorado's 2027 pick rolls over

How the Injuries Could Change the Pick's Value

The Colorado first-round pick's value moves with the Avalanche standings. A Colorado team that finishes near the top of the league produces a pick in the high 20s. A Colorado team that stumbles into a wild-card scramble produces something in the teens, which is worth considerably more on the trade market.

A short absence for either star barely moves the needle. Colorado is 11-6-3 and has the depth to survive a few games, as Thursday's comeback in Ottawa showed. A long absence for both would be different. MacKinnon and Makar drive Colorado's offence at even strength and on the power play. Weeks without them could push the Avalanche from the top of the Central toward the playoff line.

Even then, the top-10 protection is very unlikely to come into play. For the pick to land in the top 10, Colorado would need to finish among the bottom third of the league, which would require a collapse far beyond a few weeks of injuries. The realistic range is still the late teens to late 20s.

There is a second, less obvious effect. Colorado itself may become a more urgent buyer if its stars miss time, which tends to tighten the market for the kind of defenceman Toronto wants. Every contender that loses a key player and starts shopping is one more competitor for the same short list of available players. That is another reason for Chayka to move sooner rather than later.

For Toronto that is mildly good news. A weaker Colorado season makes the pick more attractive to a seller, and sellers value certainty. The Leafs will not root for injuries, and nobody should. But a pick that might land at 16 instead of 28 is a better centrepiece for a trade.

Chayka Is Already Talking About Spending It

The pick is not likely to stay in Toronto for long. Elliotte Friedman, in comments relayed from the FAN Hockey Show this week, said the Leafs are prepared to move a premium asset for a difference-maker on defence, and that Colorado's first is on the table. Pierre LeBrun reported on TSN on Nov. 12 that Chayka continues to make calls about a meaningful blue-line upgrade, describing it as a priority item.

That fits the logic of the roster. The Leafs have lost five straight, Morgan Rielly is out with a lower-body injury, and Chris Tanev is on a managed workload. A first-round pick in a year Toronto otherwise has none is exactly the asset that unlocks a significant trade.

Our earlier explainer on the Leafs' 2027 draft picks made the point that the Colorado pick was always more likely to be currency than a selection. The past two weeks have only strengthened that.

Our Take: Use It While It Is Worth the Most

There is an argument for waiting. If Colorado's injuries linger and the Avalanche slide in December, the pick projects higher and buys more at the deadline. Chayka could, in theory, sit on it and let its value rise.

We would not. The Leafs are 8-11-2 and their own season is the asset that is losing value fastest. Every week without a defenceman costs Toronto points it cannot get back. A pick that projects to 22nd in mid-November is still a first-round pick, and teams will price it as one. Waiting for it to become 17th while the Leafs fall further out of a playoff spot is the wrong trade-off.

The pick also has a natural expiry on its usefulness. After the 2027 draft, Toronto does not hold another first until 2029. If Chayka wants to make a major trade before then involving a first-round pick, this is the one.

What's Next

Watch Colorado's injury update before Saturday's game in Montreal. If MacKinnon and Makar are listed day-to-day, nothing changes. If either is placed on injured reserve, the Avalanche's next two weeks become worth following from Toronto, and you can track both teams on the standings page.

The Leafs, meanwhile, close their homestand against Edmonton on Nov. 14 and visit Chicago on Nov. 17. Whatever happens in Denver, the Colorado first-round pick is Toronto's best trade chip. The sooner it becomes a defenceman, the better.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do the Maple Leafs have Colorado's first-round pick?

Yes. Toronto owns Colorado's 2027 first-round pick, acquired in the Nicolas Roy trade on March 5, 2026. It is top-10 protected. If it lands in the top 10, Toronto receives Colorado's unprotected 2028 first-round pick instead.

Who has the Maple Leafs' 2027 first-round pick?

The Boston Bruins. Toronto's 2027 first was owed to Boston from the Brandon Carlo trade of March 7, 2025, because the 2026 first was top-five protected and became Gavin McKenna, the first overall pick. Toronto's own 2028 first is owed to Philadelphia from the Scott Laughton trade.

Are Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar injured?

Both left Colorado's 4-3 overtime loss to Ottawa on Nov. 12, 2026 in the second period with lower-body injuries and did not return. As of Nov. 14, coach Jared Bednar had given no update, and both travelled with the team to Montreal with their status uncertain.

What is the Avalanche's record in 2026-27?

After the Nov. 12 overtime loss in Ottawa, Colorado was 11-6-3 and third in the Central Division, with points in four straight games. The Avalanche beat the Maple Leafs 6-3 in Toronto on Nov. 10.

Will the Leafs trade the Colorado first-round pick?

It is the likeliest centrepiece of any major trade. Elliotte Friedman has said Toronto is willing to move a premium asset, including Colorado's first, for a difference-making defenceman, and Pierre LeBrun reported on Nov. 12, 2026 that GM John Chayka is making calls about a blue-line upgrade.

What happens if Colorado's pick lands in the top 10?

Toronto would get Colorado's unprotected 2028 first-round pick instead. Because Colorado had already traded that 2028 pick, now held by Nashville, the Predators would receive Colorado's 2029 first as compensation. A top-10 finish is very unlikely for an Avalanche team that is 11-6-3.

Share this article

Explore topics