
Photo: NHL.com
William Nylander's 103-Point Pace Hides a Puck Problem Hiller Is Right to Fix
Table of Contents
William Nylander's numbers do not agree with each other
William Nylander has 10 goals and 21 points in 17 games, second on the Maple Leafs in both, and is on pace for 49 goals and 103 points. He is also, by the measure that usually predicts what comes next, having the worst puck-possession season of his career. According to TSN, Toronto is controlling just 43.7 per cent of the even-strength shot attempts when Nylander is on the ice, which would be a career-worst mark.
Nylander called it "a weird season in that way" when asked about it on Wednesday, Nov. 4, telling reporters he does not feel he has had the puck on his stick as much as usual. Head coach Jim Hiller agreed, and offered a fix. LeafsLurker's view: Hiller has diagnosed this correctly, and the Leafs cannot afford to wait for the points to dry up before acting on it.
The production is real
Start with what is going right, because it is a lot. Nylander passed Rick Vaive for sixth on the franchise goals list when he scored his 300th in the 7-2 win in Edmonton on Oct. 24. He tied his career high with five points in Toronto's 6-3 win in Denver on Oct. 10. TSN also has him on pace for a career high in average ice time at 20:11 a night.
At 30, on an $11.5 million cap hit with a no-move clause through 2031-32, he is still one of the best value contracts on the team relative to his output. We have argued before that 50 goals is a realistic target for him this season, and the current pace says that was not a reach.
Here is how the two halves of his season compare:
| Measure | Nylander, 2026-27 | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | 10 in 17 games | 49-goal pace |
| Points | 21 in 17 games | 103-point pace |
| Average ice time | 20:11 | Career-high pace |
| Even-strength shot-attempt share | 43.7 per cent | Career-worst pace |
Figures are from TSN's Nov. 4 report and cover the season through the Nov. 3 loss to Utah.
Why the shot share matters more than the points
A 43.7 per cent shot-attempt share means that for every 100 attempts at even strength with Nylander on the ice, the other team is taking about 56. That is not a hot streak problem. It is a territory problem. Toronto is spending more of Nylander's shifts defending than attacking, and his points are coming despite that, not because of it.
That kind of gap tends to close one of two ways. Either the possession numbers improve and the points keep coming, or the shooting luck evens out and the points fall back toward what the underlying play supports. Elite finishers like Nylander can beat the averages for longer than most, but no one beats them for a full season while chasing the puck for most of their even-strength minutes.
It also fits the wider picture. Hiller said on Wednesday, per The Leafs Nation, that "we're spending too much time in our own zone," and Toronto's 3-2 loss to Utah on Nov. 3 was the latest example: Sergei Bobrovsky faced 36 shots and needed 33 saves to keep the Leafs in it. We covered that one in our recap of the Utah loss.
What Hiller wants from Nylander
Hiller's fix is specific. "Maybe spend less time in the neutral zone waiting for the puck, and more time in our own zone trying to be the breakout outlet who can carry it," he said, as quoted by Maple Leafs Hot Stove on Nov. 4.
He also described the version of Nylander he remembers from his first stint with the Maple Leafs: a player who carried the puck through the neutral zone, took defenders wide, turned up ice and found a second option. Hiller said Nylander simply has not had many of those looks this season.
That is a fair description of how Nylander's best seasons have worked. He is at his most dangerous when he gets the puck with speed in his own half and drives the neutral zone himself. Waiting at the far blue line for a stretch pass is efficient when it works, and it produces goals off the rush, but it also means Nylander is out of the play when the breakout fails. On a team that is losing the territorial battle, the breakout fails a lot.
The trade-off
Asking Nylander to come deeper is not free. It means more time in his own end, more puck touches under pressure along the wall, and probably fewer of the cheap rush chances he has been finishing. The bet Hiller is making is that Nylander carrying the puck out cleanly is worth more than Nylander waiting for it, because each clean exit turns a defensive shift into an offensive one.
That bet is the right one. Nylander's skating and puck protection are his most valuable tools, and using them in the most important area of the ice, the breakout, is a better use of a $11.5 million player than having him hover in the neutral zone hoping a defenceman gets the puck to him.
The Tavares factor
The lineup is changing around Nylander, too. At Wednesday's practice, John Tavares skated at left wing on a line with Nick Paul and Nylander, his first full session with the group since his Oct. 15 injury. Hiller said Friday's practice will decide whether Tavares plays Saturday against Montreal. The full status update is in our Tavares return report.
For Nylander, that combination makes sense. Tavares has never been a fast skater, but he wins pucks on the wall, sees the ice well and makes a clean first pass. Paul gives the line a centre who can take defensive-zone draws and cover low. If Hiller wants Nylander to be the player who carries the puck out, a line with two responsible forwards who can get it to him in motion is the right structure.
It also takes Nylander away from the young-player experiment that did not work earlier this season. Toronto tried Gavin McKenna with Tavares and Nylander earlier this season, and that line was badly outshot, which we wrote about at the time. This version is more defensively sound by design.
The risk if nothing changes
The Leafs are 8-7-2 with 18 points after 17 games, and their offence has carried more of the load than their defence. If Nylander's points slow down while the shot share stays where it is, Toronto loses one of the main reasons it is even at .500 or better.
There is also a bigger-picture point. John Chayka has spent the fall looking for a defenceman, and the trade market has been the main story around the team. But no trade fixes a forward group that spends too long in its own end. The forwards have to get the puck out, too, and Nylander, as the team's highest-paid winger, is a fair place to start. You can see where every Leaf stands on the players page.
What's next
The test starts Saturday, Nov. 7, against Montreal, a fast team that thrives on rush chances. Watch where Nylander is when Toronto wins the puck in its own end. If he is low, collecting it and carrying it out, Hiller's message has landed. If he is at the far blue line waiting, the 103-point pace may hold for a while, but the shot share says it will not hold forever.
LeafsLurker's position is that Nylander's season is good but fragile, and that Hiller is right to push him now while the points are still coming. A coach who waits for the production to drop before addressing the underlying problem has waited too long.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many points does William Nylander have this season?
Through the Nov. 3 loss to Utah, Nylander had 10 goals and 21 points in 17 games, second on the Maple Leafs in both categories. TSN had him on pace for 49 goals and 103 points.
What is William Nylander's Corsi this season?
Per TSN, the Leafs are controlling 43.7 per cent of even-strength shot attempts with Nylander on the ice, which would be the worst mark of his career. That means opponents are taking roughly 56 of every 100 attempts during his even-strength shifts.
What did Jim Hiller say about William Nylander?
On Nov. 4, Hiller said Nylander should 'maybe spend less time in the neutral zone waiting for the puck, and more time in our own zone trying to be the breakout outlet who can carry it,' as quoted by Maple Leafs Hot Stove. Nylander called it 'a weird season in that way' because he has not had the puck as much.
How much is William Nylander's contract?
Nylander carries an $11.5 million cap hit through the 2031-32 season with a no-move clause. He is the highest-paid winger on the Maple Leafs.
Did William Nylander score his 300th goal?
Yes. Nylander scored twice in Toronto's 7-2 win in Edmonton on Oct. 24, 2026, reaching 300 NHL goals and passing Rick Vaive for sixth on the Maple Leafs' all-time goals list.
How old is William Nylander?
Nylander was born May 1, 1996, which makes him 30 during the 2026-27 season. He was drafted eighth overall by Toronto in 2014.


