Skip to main content
John Tavares Return: Hiller Tests Him on the Wing as Groulx Clears Waivers

Photo: NHL.com

News

John Tavares Return: Hiller Tests Him on the Wing as Groulx Clears Waivers

LeafsLurkerNov 5, 20267 min read

Table of Contents

John Tavares return: back at practice, on the wing

The John Tavares return moved a real step closer on Wednesday, Nov. 4. The Maple Leafs centre practised with the full group for the first time since his Oct. 15 lower-body injury, wearing a red non-contact sweater, and he did it at left wing on a line with Nick Paul and William Nylander. Head coach Jim Hiller said afterward that Tavares looked "really good," according to TSN, and that Friday's practice will decide whether he plays Saturday, Nov. 7, against the Montreal Canadiens at Scotiabank Arena.

The club had already upgraded Tavares from week-to-week to day-to-day on Nov. 3, the same day Bo Groulx cleared waivers and was assigned to the AHL's Toronto Marlies. Put together, the two moves mean Toronto has an open roster spot waiting for its 36-year-old, and a coach who is already thinking about using him somewhere other than centre.

Here is where things stand, what the wing experiment says about Hiller's thinking, and what has to happen before Saturday.

The timeline since the Buffalo game

Tavares was hurt in the third period of Toronto's 5-4 overtime loss to the Buffalo Sabres on Oct. 15 and went on injured reserve days later. Reports at the time pointed to an absence of several weeks. We laid out how the Leafs planned to cover centre without him two days after the injury, and on Monday we reported that he had skated on his own before practice for the first time.

The steps since then have come quickly:

DateStepStatus
Oct. 15Injured vs. BuffaloWeek-to-week, then injured reserve
Nov. 2Skates alone before practiceWeek-to-week
Nov. 3Skates in non-contact jerseyUpgraded to day-to-day
Nov. 4Full practice on the wing, non-contactDay-to-day
Nov. 6Friday practiceDecision point for Saturday

The missing piece is contact. Every step so far has been in the red sweater. Hiller has framed Friday as the test, saying the plan was to get Tavares "into a practice with us, hopefully sooner rather than later, see how he does and then make the next step." If he takes contact on Friday and wakes up fine on Saturday, he plays. If not, the Sunday, Nov. 8 game against the New Jersey Devils, the back half of a back-to-back, is the next realistic target.

Not everyone covering the team is convinced Saturday is likely. The Leafs Nation reported that a return against Montreal did not look probable, and others have argued Toronto should wait until he has a full contact practice behind him. Officially, he is day-to-day and still on injured reserve until the club activates him.

Why Tavares is practising at left wing

The more interesting news is where Tavares lined up. Wednesday's lines, as reported by The Leafs Nation and Maple Leafs Hot Stove, looked like this:

LineLeft wingCentreRight wing
FirstEaston CowanAuston MatthewsVinni Lettieri
SecondJohn TavaresNick PaulWilliam Nylander
ThirdDakota JoshuaColton SissonsGavin McKenna
FourthBrandon DuhaimeTeddy BluegerZack MacEwen

Lettieri was only on the top line because Jack Roslovic took a maintenance day. Roslovic scored both Toronto goals in Tuesday's 3-2 loss to Utah and should be back with Matthews and Cowan when it matters.

The Tavares-on-the-wing idea is not about Tavares' skating or his health, at least not according to Hiller. The coach tied it to a team-wide problem, telling reporters, per The Leafs Nation, that "we're spending too much time in our own zone." Paul has been the second-line centre since Tavares went down, and he has handled the defensive work of the position well enough that Hiller does not appear eager to pull him off it. Moving Tavares to the left side keeps Paul's faceoffs and defensive-zone coverage in the middle while adding a winger who wins puck battles along the wall and plays the net front on the power play.

There is a second reason, and it is Nylander. Hiller said on Wednesday that he wants Nylander carrying the puck out of his own end more often, rather than waiting for it in the neutral zone. A winger with Tavares' hockey sense who can retrieve pucks and make the first pass gives Nylander a better chance of doing that. We get into the Nylander side of this in our column on his puck-possession numbers.

The case for and against the move

LeafsLurker's view: it is worth trying, and it should not be treated as permanent.

The case for is simple. Tavares is 36, coming off three weeks out, and centre is the most demanding forward position on a team that Hiller says is stuck in its own end. Taking defensive-zone draws and low coverage off his plate in his first few games back is sensible load management. Paul, at a $3.15 million cap hit through 2028-29, has earned the chance to keep the job.

The case against is that Tavares has been one of Toronto's better faceoff men for years, and the Leafs' depth at centre is thin. Sissons and Blueger are useful bottom-six players, but neither drives offence. If Paul's line starts giving up chances or losing draws, the most natural fix is to flip Tavares and Paul. Hiller can make that switch in the middle of a game, which is part of the appeal of having two centres on one line.

The other cost falls on McKenna. The 18-year-old was moved to the third line with Joshua and Sissons this week, a decision we argued gives him the wrong linemates. With Tavares and Nylander together on the second line, there is no easy route back into the top six for McKenna until something changes.

Groulx clears waivers and the roster math

Groulx was placed on waivers on Monday, Nov. 2, to make room after Joshua's return from injury, and he went unclaimed. The Leafs assigned him to the Marlies, where he was part of the 2026 Calder Cup run. He carries an $812,500 cap hit in the final year of his contract, and you can see the full sheet on our Leafs contracts page.

The practical effect is roster space. With Groulx gone and Tavares and Kirill Marchenko on injured reserve, The Hockey News reported that Toronto is carrying 21 players, two under the 23-man maximum. That means activating Tavares does not require a corresponding move. The Leafs can simply take him off injured reserve and drop an extra forward from the lineup.

Marchenko is the other name to watch. He was ruled week-to-week with a lower-body injury on Oct. 28 after being hurt in Calgary on Oct. 26 and was placed on injured reserve the next day. He had six goals and 14 points in 14 games before he was hurt, as we covered in what the Leafs lose without him. There has been no public update on a return date. When he does come back, the roster gets tighter and the next waiver decision follows.

Who comes out when Tavares goes in

Based on Wednesday's practice, Lettieri is the obvious odd man out once Roslovic returns. But Tavares' return also squeezes someone who played on Tuesday. The 12 forwards above, with Roslovic swapped back in for Lettieri, do not leave room for anyone else.

That is a good problem to have for a team that is 8-7-2 with 18 points. Toronto has played since Oct. 15 without its second-line centre, without Marchenko since Oct. 26, and for stretches without Chris Tanev and Jake McCabe on the blue line. Tanev and McCabe were back together in Wednesday's defence pairs, with McCabe alongside Darren Raddysh, Morgan Rielly with Tanev, and Oliver Ekman-Larsson with Troy Stecher. Anthony Stolarz and Sergei Bobrovsky were both on the ice.

What's next

The sequence is clear. Friday's practice is the contact test. If Tavares gets through it, he will likely be activated off injured reserve on Saturday morning and play against Montreal, a team that beat Toronto 3-2 on opening night and is coming off a historic collapse against Winnipeg. If he does not, New Jersey on Sunday is the next opportunity.

The bigger question is whether the wing experiment survives the first week. Hiller's diagnosis, that the Leafs spend too much time defending, is correct. Whether Tavares on the left side fixes it, or whether he ends up back at centre by the third period of his first game, will say a lot about what Hiller really thinks of his centre depth. The full six-game slate is in our homestand preview, and the standings picture is on the standings page.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is John Tavares coming back from injury?

Tavares was upgraded to day-to-day on Nov. 3 and practised with the full group in a non-contact jersey on Nov. 4. Jim Hiller said Friday's practice on Nov. 6 will decide whether he plays Saturday, Nov. 7, against Montreal. If not, the Nov. 8 game against New Jersey is the next target.

What injury does John Tavares have?

Tavares has a lower-body injury suffered in the third period of Toronto's 5-4 overtime loss to Buffalo on Oct. 15. The Leafs listed him as week-to-week and placed him on injured reserve before upgrading him to day-to-day on Nov. 3.

Is John Tavares playing wing for the Maple Leafs?

At the Nov. 4 practice, Tavares skated at left wing on a line with Nick Paul at centre and William Nylander on the right. Hiller tied the change to the team spending too much time in its own zone. It is a practice look, and he could still move back to centre.

Did Bo Groulx clear waivers?

Yes. The Leafs placed Bo Groulx on waivers on Nov. 2, he went unclaimed and he was assigned to the AHL's Toronto Marlies. He carries an $812,500 cap hit in the final year of his contract.

How many players are on the Maple Leafs roster?

After Groulx was assigned to the Marlies, The Hockey News reported Toronto was carrying 21 players, two below the 23-man maximum. Tavares and Kirill Marchenko are on injured reserve, so Tavares can be activated without a corresponding move.

What is John Tavares' contract with the Maple Leafs?

Tavares carries a $4.38 million cap hit through the 2028-29 season. He has a no-move clause through June 30, 2027, followed by a five-team modified no-trade list.

When do the Maple Leafs play the Canadiens?

Toronto hosts Montreal at Scotiabank Arena on Saturday, Nov. 7, the second game of a six-game homestand. The Canadiens beat the Leafs 3-2 in the Sept. 29 season opener.

Share this article