
Photo: NHL.com
William Nylander Slump: Hiller Is Right, but Break Up the Tavares Line
Table of Contents
The William Nylander Slump, by the Numbers
The William Nylander slump is now big enough that his coach is talking about it in public. After the 6-3 loss to Colorado on Nov. 10, Jim Hiller said, "I know he can play better than he's playing right now." Nylander was minus-4 that night, on the ice for four of the Avalanche's six goals, and he has one goal and no assists across Toronto's four straight losses.
Our take: Hiller is right, and he was right to say it. But the fix is not a speech. The Ryan Tverberg-John Tavares-Nylander line is not working, and Hiller should break it up before Minnesota comes to town on Thursday.
Context matters here. Nylander still has 22 points (11 goals, 11 assists) in 20 games, per ESPN's game log. He scored his 300th career goal against Edmonton in October. This is a cold stretch from an elite player, not a crisis. It just happens to be landing during the worst week of Toronto's season.
What Hiller Actually Said
It is worth reading the full answer, because the short version making the rounds sounds harsher than it was. Hiller called it "a pretty fair statement" that Nylander could be better and said Nylander would agree if asked. He also said it was not only on Nylander and that the line as a whole had not been good, per The Leafs Nation and The Hockey News.
Then he backed his player. He called Nylander "a hell of a player" who "will get out of it," and said he has to be a driver for this team. That's a coach applying pressure and support in the same breath. It's how you handle a star with an $11.5 million cap hit and a no-movement clause through 2032, and it is a lot more direct than the Leafs used to be with their top players.
We have been here before with this coaching staff. Earlier this month we wrote that Nylander's point pace was hiding a puck problem: turnovers and low-percentage plays at the blue line. The points have dried up since, and the puck problem has not.
The Line Is Losing Badly
The underlying numbers from the Colorado game are hard to defend. Here is how the Tverberg-Tavares-Nylander line did at five-on-five, per Maple Leafs Hot Stove and The Leafs Nation:
| Measure | Leafs | Avalanche |
|---|---|---|
| Shot attempts | 7 | 17 |
| Goals | 0 | 2 |
| Expected-goals share | About 18% | About 82% |
An 18 per cent expected-goals share is a line spending almost all its time in its own end. Against Nathan MacKinnon, Cale Makar and that Colorado group, that is how you lose. Maple Leafs Hot Stove's review argued that Tverberg, the call-up, was not the issue and that the veterans were. Hiller seemed to agree, saying of Tverberg, "I thought he was really good."
That leaves Tavares and Nylander. Tavares is 36 and only recently back from the injury that kept him out for much of late October. He is a smart, positionally sound centre, but he is not going to carry a line through the neutral zone against a fast team. Nylander is at his best with the puck on his stick and speed through the middle. When his centre cannot get the line out of its own end, Nylander ends up chasing, and chasing is not his game.
Three Ways to Fix It
Hiller has options, even with Kirill Marchenko and Colton Sissons out. Here is how we would rank them:
1. Put Nylander back with Matthews for a stretch
The obvious move is to reunite Nylander with Auston Matthews. It concentrates the team's two best forwards on one line, which costs depth, but depth is not what is losing games right now. Matthews was involved on the Raddysh goal against Colorado and has been the team's most consistent forward all season. We made the case for a Matthews-Nylander pairing before the season, and the argument is stronger now.
2. Give Tavares a puck-carrier, not a finisher
If Hiller wants to keep Nylander with Tavares, the third forward needs to move the puck up ice. Easton Cowan scored against Colorado and has been one of the team's best young players. Putting him on that line would add pace and give Nylander a second puck-mover.
3. Move Nylander to centre on the second line
This one is more radical. Nylander has played centre before and likes having the puck in the middle of the ice. With Sissons out, Toronto is short at centre anyway. It's a gamble, and we would only try it for a game or two, but it would get Nylander the puck in motion more often.
Why the William Nylander Slump Matters Now
The Leafs are 8-10-2 and have been outscored 17-7 in four straight losses. They have no margin left, and the team's scoring is concentrated in very few players. Jack Roslovic has 20 points, and Matthews has been the engine all season. After those three, the drop-off is steep. When Nylander goes cold, there's nobody to cover for it.
That is also why the Leafs need a forward from outside. We wrote this week that GM John Chayka cannot wait for Marchenko, and Nylander's slump is part of that argument. A team with one hot line and one cold one can't win in this conference.
Nylander's contract also shapes how this plays out. At $11.5 million through 2032 with full move protection, he isn't going anywhere, and nobody serious is suggesting he should. The Leafs' contract sheet makes it plain: he and Matthews are the core. The only question is how to get the most out of him.
Hiller's Call-Out Was the Right Call
Some fans will say a coach should never single out a star after a loss. We disagree. Hiller has been consistent since he took over in June: he benched Gavin McKenna when the rookie's effort dipped, and he has been blunt about the team's results. Applying the same standard to Nylander is fair, and it tells the room nobody gets a pass.
It also matters how he did it. He did not bench Nylander or cut his minutes. He said what everyone watching could see and then said Nylander would get out of it. That is a coach protecting his credibility without burning his best winger.
What's Next
Minnesota visits Scotiabank Arena on Thursday, Nov. 12, with a 13-3-4 record and one of the league's stingiest defences over the last 10 games. That is a hard place to break a slump. It is also a good test of whether Hiller's words come with a lineup change.
Hiller could also lean on special teams to get Nylander going. A power-play goal has a way of loosening up a frustrated scorer, and Toronto will need its top unit to beat a Wild team built to keep games tight. Giving Nylander extra time on the first unit costs nothing and rewards the thing he does best: shooting from the flank with time and space.
Our bet: Nylander scores again this week. Players of his quality don't stay cold for long. But if the Tavares line stays together and gets caved in again, the coaching staff will own that as much as Nylander does. Split it up, and see what happens.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Jim Hiller say about William Nylander?
After the 6-3 loss to Colorado on Nov. 10, 2026, Hiller said, "I know he can play better than he's playing right now," and called that a fair statement Nylander would agree with. He also said it was not only Nylander's fault, called him "a hell of a player" and said he would get out of it.
How many points does William Nylander have this season?
Nylander has 22 points (11 goals, 11 assists) in 20 games in 2026-27, per ESPN's game log. That is still better than a point per game, but he has one goal and no assists in Toronto's four straight losses.
What was Nylander's plus-minus against the Avalanche?
Nylander was minus-4 in the 6-3 loss to Colorado on Nov. 10, 2026. He was on the ice for four of the Avalanche's six goals, per The Canadian Press.
Who is William Nylander playing with?
Against Colorado, Nylander played on a line with John Tavares and recalled forward Ryan Tverberg. That line lost the shot-attempt battle 17-7 and was outscored 2-0, per Maple Leafs Hot Stove.
How much is William Nylander's contract?
Nylander carries an $11.5 million cap hit through 2031-32 with a no-movement clause. He is the Leafs' second-highest-paid player behind Auston Matthews at $13.25 million.
Is William Nylander in a slump?
Yes, by his standards. He has one goal and zero assists across Toronto's four straight losses from Nov. 3 to Nov. 10, 2026, after a strong October that included his 300th career goal on Oct. 24 against Edmonton.


