
Photo: NHL.com
Sergei Bobrovsky's .881: Chayka's Benefit of the Doubt Should Run Out
Table of Contents
Sergei Bobrovsky has a .881 save percentage through 13 starts as a Maple Leaf, and on Monday, Nov. 16, general manager John Chayka said Toronto will keep giving him "the benefit of the doubt." That is a defensible thing for a GM to say in public. It is the wrong thing for a coach to act on in the crease. Anthony Stolarz has been the better goalie all season, and with the Leafs nine points out of a playoff spot, Sergei Bobrovsky should have to win the net back rather than be handed it.
This is an opinion piece, but the numbers underneath it are not in dispute. Here is the case.
What Chayka said about Sergei Bobrovsky
Chayka addressed his goaltender during the same availability in which he backed head coach Jim Hiller after an 0-6-0 homestand. According to The Globe and Mail and The Hockey News, he said that given Bobrovsky's body of work, it was "deserved and prudent to give him the benefit of the doubt" and let him get back in the net and stop the next puck. He described Bobrovsky as a process-oriented veteran who has "kind of been through everything in his career," and framed 13 starts as a small sample a quarter of the way into the season.
Every part of that is true. Bobrovsky is a two-time Vezina Trophy winner (2013 and 2017 with Columbus) and backstopped the Florida Panthers to back-to-back Stanley Cups in 2024 and 2025. Thirteen starts is a small sample. Goalies are notoriously streaky. None of it changes what the last six weeks have looked like.
Bobrovsky vs. Stolarz: the 2026-27 numbers
The two goalies have combined for every one of Toronto's 22 decisions, and the split is stark:
| Goalie | Games | Record | Save % | GAA | Cap hit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sergei Bobrovsky | 13 starts | 3-8-2 | .881 | 3.47 | $7.0M through 2028-29 |
| Anthony Stolarz | 9 games | 5-4-0 | .906 | 2.69 | $3.75M through 2029-30 |
Bobrovsky's line is from CBC's report on Chayka's availability; Stolarz's is from ESPN and Elite Prospects. Contract details are from the Leafs contracts page.
A .881 save percentage is not a slump at the margins. It sits well below what a starting goalie needs to keep a team in games, and it has come behind a defence Chayka himself says has improved over the last 10 games. The Leafs have won three of Bobrovsky's 13 starts and more than half of Stolarz's nine appearances. If the skaters in front of both goalies are the same, the difference is the goaltending.
Put it in practical terms. Over a typical 28-shot night, the difference between .881 and .906 is roughly 0.7 goals per game. Across Bobrovsky's 13 starts, that is about nine goals. Toronto lost six straight while scoring only nine goals on the homestand, so there is no offensive cushion to absorb that leak. In a month where the Leafs have been shut out twice and dropped several one- and two-goal games, nine goals is the gap between last in the Atlantic and the thick of the wild-card race.
Why the Leafs keep going back to Bobrovsky
There are understandable reasons the organization is leaning on Bobrovsky, and it is worth being fair about them.
- The contract. Chayka signed Bobrovsky to a three-year, $21-million deal in July, with a no-movement clause. The front office has an obvious interest in that signing working.
- Track record. Bobrovsky has delivered in big moments for a decade. The bet is that his process holds and the results follow.
- Workload. Toronto plays an 84-game schedule this season. No one wants to bury Stolarz under 60 starts, and Stolarz has missed time with injuries in past seasons.
We covered the signing in detail in the original breakdown of the three-year, $21-million deal. The logic was sound in July. The question is whether it still governs who starts on a Tuesday in November when the season is slipping.
There is also a dressing-room argument. Goalies who are pulled from the No. 1 role sometimes press harder, and a veteran who has spent most of his career as a starter may not respond well to a public demotion. That is a reason to handle the change carefully, not a reason to avoid it. A clear, stated standard is easier on a proud veteran than a quiet benching after another three-goal night.
The case for riding Anthony Stolarz now
Stolarz turns 33 in January and is signed through 2029-30 at $3.75 million, which makes him one of the better-value goalies in the league if he keeps stopping pucks at this rate. He has been the Leafs' most reliable goalie since opening week, including the 2-1 win over the Islanders that gave Hiller his first victory. We argued as far back as late October that Stolarz had earned the net, and the gap has only widened.
"Benefit of the doubt" is a phrase for teams with margin. Toronto has none. TSN had the Leafs nine points behind Florida for the last wild-card spot after the homestand. Every point given away to protect a veteran's confidence is a point the team may need in April.
This is not a call to bench Bobrovsky indefinitely or to talk about buying out a 38-year-old with two years left after this one. It is a call for the crease to work the way the rest of the lineup is supposed to: the better player plays.
A plan for the next seven games
The schedule makes this easier. Toronto's next seven games, starting in Chicago on Nov. 17, are all against teams outside the playoff picture, per The Globe and Mail. That stretch includes a back-to-back in Boston and Pittsburgh on Nov. 27-28.
LeafsLurker's proposal:
- Stolarz starts at least four of the seven, including the home games against Los Angeles on Nov. 19 and Columbus on Nov. 21.
- Bobrovsky takes one half of the Boston-Pittsburgh back-to-back and one other game of the coaches' choosing.
- If Bobrovsky posts .910 or better in those starts, the split returns to something close to even in December. If he does not, Stolarz becomes the clear No. 1.
That keeps Bobrovsky involved, protects Stolarz from overuse, and turns "benefit of the doubt" into something measurable. It also gives Hiller cover: a coach whose GM just publicly backed him should not be the one sacrificed for a goaltending decision.
The risk of being wrong either way
If Chayka is right and Bobrovsky snaps back to form, the Leafs gain a goalie capable of stealing a playoff series, which Stolarz has not yet shown over a long stretch. That is the upside the organization is protecting, and it is real.
But the downside is worse. If Bobrovsky keeps playing at .881 through the end of November, Toronto could be well into double-digit points out of a playoff spot by Dec. 1, the date that historically separates contenders from sellers. Our playoff-odds breakdown shows how little room is left. At that point a goaltending call becomes a franchise call, with Auston Matthews' contract running through 2027-28.
What's next
Bobrovsky was the projected starter for Tuesday's game against the Blackhawks, according to The Leafs Nation's lineup report. Fine: the benefit of the doubt starts now. But it should come with a short leash and a clear standard, because Stolarz has already met it. If Toronto is going to climb out of last place in the Atlantic, it will do it with the goalie who is stopping pucks, not the one with the better résumé.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Sergei Bobrovsky's save percentage with the Maple Leafs?
Through his first 13 starts of 2026-27, Bobrovsky had an .881 save percentage and a 3.47 goals-against average with a 3-8-2 record, per CBC's report on Nov. 16, 2026.
How long is Sergei Bobrovsky's contract with the Maple Leafs?
Bobrovsky signed a three-year, $21-million contract with Toronto in July 2026, a $7-million cap hit that runs through 2028-29. The deal includes a no-movement clause.
Who is the Maple Leafs' starting goalie?
Toronto has split the net between Sergei Bobrovsky and Anthony Stolarz in 2026-27, with Bobrovsky taking 13 of the first 22 starts. GM John Chayka said on Nov. 16 the club will give Bobrovsky the benefit of the doubt, though Stolarz has the better numbers at 5-4-0 and .906.
What did John Chayka say about Sergei Bobrovsky?
Chayka said that, given Bobrovsky's body of work, it was "deserved and prudent to give him the benefit of the doubt." He described the 38-year-old as a process-oriented veteran who has been through everything in his career.
How old is Sergei Bobrovsky?
Sergei Bobrovsky was born on Sept. 20, 1988, making him 38 years old during the 2026-27 season. He is a two-time Vezina Trophy winner and won the Stanley Cup with Florida in 2024 and 2025.
How much does Anthony Stolarz make?
Anthony Stolarz carries a $3.75-million cap hit with the Maple Leafs through the 2029-30 season, and his contract includes a modified no-trade clause.


