Skip to main content
Simon Edvinsson Trade: Two Weeks to Dec. 1 and the Leafs Should Call

Photo: NHL.com

Opinion

Simon Edvinsson Trade: Two Weeks to Dec. 1 and the Leafs Should Call

LeafsLurkerNov 17, 20266 min read

Table of Contents

The Simon Edvinsson trade clock now has two weeks left on it. The 23-year-old Detroit Red Wings defenceman is still an unsigned restricted free agent, and under NHL rules he must sign by 4 p.m. ET on Dec. 1 or sit out the 2026-27 NHL season. With Detroit's interim GM Shawn Horcoff now openly taking calls and John Chayka admitting on Nov. 16 that Toronto's blue line "hasn't been where we want it," the Maple Leafs should make one serious run at a Simon Edvinsson trade before the deadline, and be ready to walk away if the price is a roster player they cannot replace.

That is LeafsLurker's position. Here is the state of the market and why the math is closer than it looks.

Where the Simon Edvinsson trade standoff stands

Edvinsson, the sixth overall pick in 2021, has been without a contract since the summer. The gap is money and term. Daily Faceoff's David Pagnotta has reported that his camp is seeking a long-term deal at roughly $11 million per season, while Detroit initially preferred a shorter bridge contract. Reports since have said the Red Wings are open to discussing longer terms, but no agreement has been reported.

Horcoff's public stance has shifted. On Oct. 14, he told reporters he had "zero interest" in trading Edvinsson. At the NHL general managers' meetings in Toronto earlier this month, he said he would still like to sign him but that it was his job to do what is in Detroit's best interest, and that he would take the calls and hear what teams had to say. Most recently he described the situation as status quo.

There is also a European wrinkle. Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman has said reporters based in Sweden believe Edvinsson is prepared to play there if Dec. 1 passes without a deal, though Detroit Hockey Now reported on Nov. 17 that a Swedish source said that bridge would only be crossed if Dec. 1 passes without a contract.

Who else wants Edvinsson

The market is crowded, which is both the problem and the opportunity. Here is what has been reported about interested clubs this fall:

ReportWhenTeams named
NHL insider roundupLate OctoberSt. Louis Blues, Philadelphia Flyers, Utah Mammoth, Toronto Maple Leafs, Boston Bruins
David Pagnotta, Daily FaceoffOctoberCarolina Hurricanes, San Jose Sharks, Toronto Maple Leafs
Pierre LeBrunAutumnAt least 10 teams have inquired
The Fourth PeriodNov. 9Six teams identified as interested

Toronto has appeared on two separate lists, and the Leafs' interest predates their slide. We first made the case in October in why the Leafs can't sit out the Edvinsson race. What has changed since is that Toronto's need has gone from obvious to urgent.

Why the Leafs need a defenceman more than ever

The Maple Leafs are 8-12-2, last in the Atlantic Division and nine points back of Florida for the final wild-card spot, per TSN, after an 0-6-0 homestand. The blue line has been the weakest unit through much of it.

  • Morgan Rielly has been out since a lower-body injury in the Nov. 7 loss to Montreal, though he returned to practice on Nov. 16.
  • Chris Tanev, 36, is being managed through the season after an early injury, and the coaching staff has already moved him to a third-pair role.
  • Prospect Ben Danford, part of the next wave on the right side, broke his wrist earlier this month.

Chayka has said the group is older and needs youth, mobility and offence. Edvinsson is all three. A 23-year-old, 6-foot-6 left-shot defenceman who skates well for his size is precisely the profile the GM keeps describing. We detailed how thin the group gets in what the Leafs' defence looks like without Rielly.

The cap problem, and how Chayka could solve it

An $11-million ask is the obstacle. Any team acquiring Edvinsson before Dec. 1 would have to sign him, and his new cap hit would land on that team's books immediately. Chayka said Monday that the Kirill Marchenko trade gained the Leafs some cap space this season, but nowhere near enough to absorb a contract that size without sending salary back. The full breakdown is on the Leafs contracts page.

There are realistic structures, though. Detroit would almost certainly want a young roster player and a first-round pick. Toronto's tradeable picks are thinner than most contenders'. The Leafs own Colorado's 2027 first-round pick, top-10 protected, and their own 2029 first; their own 2027 and 2028 firsts were traded in earlier deals. You can check every pick on the Leafs draft picks page.

LeafsLurker's line in the sand:

  1. Yes to the Colorado 2027 first, a quality prospect and a mid-salary veteran going back to balance the cap.
  2. Yes to signing Edvinsson for seven or eight years, even near $10 million, if the term buys down the cap hit. A 23-year-old top-pair defenceman is the one asset class Toronto cannot develop fast enough internally.
  3. No to Gavin McKenna, Easton Cowan or any forward currently in the top six. Toronto scored nine goals in six games on the homestand; fixing the defence by gutting the forward group is not a fix.

Why go that far? Because the alternative path, waiting for Edvinsson to reach unrestricted free agency or hoping a comparable player appears in the summer, is not realistic. Young defencemen with his size and skating rarely reach the open market, and when they do, Toronto is competing with every team with cap room. A restricted free agent with a hard deadline and a frustrated team is about as close to a buyer's market as this position ever gets.

The risk: paying a premium for a player who has not done it yet

The honest case against is simple. Edvinsson's agent is asking for the kind of money reserved for proven top-pair defencemen, and Edvinsson has not yet been one over a full NHL career. Detroit's own hesitation on a long-term deal is a data point, not just a negotiating stance. If he lands in Toronto at $11 million and plays like a solid No. 3, the Leafs will have repeated the exact cap mistake that hurt them in previous eras.

There is also the opportunity cost. Toronto has other defence options, as we outlined in the mid-November defence trade market. Older, cheaper rentals would help this season without a long-term commitment. But none of them solves the problem Chayka himself identified: an ageing blue line that needs a player who will still be good in 2030.

What's next before Dec. 1

Three outcomes are possible in the next 14 days: Edvinsson signs in Detroit, he is traded and signs elsewhere, or he misses the NHL season. Horcoff's willingness to listen suggests the middle option is now live, and deadlines tend to force decisions in the final 72 hours.

For the Leafs, the timing lines up with the softest part of their schedule and with Chayka's own public acknowledgement that the defence needs help. Make the call, make a real offer, and keep the top-six forwards out of it. If Detroit wants more than that, let another team overpay. But do not let the deadline pass without trying, because a 23-year-old defenceman of this size and pedigree almost never shakes loose in November.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the deadline for Simon Edvinsson to sign?

As an unsigned restricted free agent, Edvinsson must sign an NHL contract by 4 p.m. ET on Dec. 1, 2026 to be eligible to play in the NHL during the 2026-27 season. If he does not, he cannot play in the league this season.

How much does Simon Edvinsson want?

Daily Faceoff's David Pagnotta reported that Edvinsson's camp is seeking a long-term contract with an average annual value of around $11 million. Detroit initially preferred a shorter bridge deal.

Are the Red Wings trading Simon Edvinsson?

Interim GM Shawn Horcoff said on Oct. 14 he had zero interest in a trade, but at the NHL GM meetings in November he said he would take calls while still hoping to sign Edvinsson. No trade had been reported as of Nov. 17, 2026.

Are the Maple Leafs interested in Simon Edvinsson?

Toronto was named among interested teams in at least two reports in October 2026, including one from David Pagnotta. GM John Chayka said on Nov. 16 he has not ruled out a trade to improve the blue line.

How old is Simon Edvinsson?

Simon Edvinsson was born on Feb. 5, 2003, making him 23 years old. The Swedish defenceman was drafted sixth overall by the Detroit Red Wings in 2021.

Will Simon Edvinsson play in Sweden?

Elliotte Friedman has reported that Sweden-based reporters believe Edvinsson is prepared to play there if he is unsigned after Dec. 1. As of Nov. 17, no agreement with a Swedish club had been reported.

Share this article