
Photo: NHL.com
Jim Hiller Says It 'Might Be Time': Four Leafs Lineup Changes to Make Now
Table of Contents
Leafs lineup changes are finally on the table. After a 6-3 loss in Chicago on Nov. 17 stretched Toronto's losing streak to seven, head coach Jim Hiller said it "might be time" for changes, that "we certainly gotta talk about it," and that his staff had "given some guys some rope and let them run with it a little bit," per theScore's account of his postgame availability. He did not say who. LeafsLurker will.
Here are the four Leafs lineup changes we would make before the Los Angeles Kings come to Scotiabank Arena on Thursday, Nov. 19. None of them require a trade, a waiver claim or a call to the Marlies. All of them use players already on the roster, and that is the point: an 8-13-2 team with a $104 million cap does not need a miracle. It needs its coach to stop protecting the same choices.
Why Leafs Lineup Changes Can't Wait
The case is in the results. Toronto has lost seven straight games in regulation, its longest losing streak since March 2015 according to The Associated Press. The Leafs were outscored 23-9 across an 0-6-0 homestand from Nov. 3 to 14, then took a 1-0 lead in Chicago and lost 6-3 to a Blackhawks team that came in with five wins in 20 games.
General manager John Chayka has stood by Hiller. On Nov. 16 he said he and Mats Sundin had "full support" behind the coach, and he argued the team's underlying play is better than its record. We broke down what Chayka said at the time. Taking him at his word, the fix is not a new coach. It is the coach making different decisions. That is what Hiller hinted at in Chicago, and Thursday is the first chance to see whether he meant it.
For reference, this was the lineup Toronto used against Chicago, per NHL.com's projected lineup and postgame coverage (defence pairs as projected):
| Unit | Players | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Top line | Easton Cowan with Auston Matthews | Cowan moved back up; scored in 20:29 |
| Second line | Ryan Tverberg, John Tavares, William Nylander | Tverberg on the line since Nov. 10 |
| Third line | Gavin McKenna, Nick Paul, Dakota Joshua | McKenna assisted on Tavares goal |
| Defence pairs | Jake McCabe and Darren Raddysh; Oliver Ekman-Larsson and Chris Tanev; Morgan Rielly and Troy Stecher | Rielly back from four-game absence |
| Scratches | Brendan Brisson, Cole McWard, Dakota Mermis | Brisson recalled Nov. 12 |
Change 1: Anthony Stolarz Starts Against the Kings
Start with the net, because it is the easiest call. Sergei Bobrovsky allowed six goals on 25 shots in Chicago and is now 3-9-2. He was at .881 before the game, per TSN, and ClutchPoints had him at .874 afterward. Anthony Stolarz is 5-4-0 with a .906 save percentage and lost his last start 1-0 to Edmonton on Nov. 14, when Toronto could not score on Devon Levi.
Hiller said after Chicago that he never considered pulling Bobrovsky, and that the blame is shared. Fine. Sharing the blame is a message to a dressing room. Choosing the starter is a hockey decision, and the numbers have favoured Stolarz all season. Bobrovsky's $7 million cap hit and no-move clause on the contracts page mean the Leafs need him eventually. They do not need him on Thursday. We made the longer case in our Bobrovsky column.
Change 2: Gavin McKenna to the Second Line
Ryan Tverberg was recalled from the Marlies on Nov. 10 and dropped onto the second line with Tavares and Nylander when Colton Sissons went down. Hiller called him a worker who brings energy, and that is a fair description. Tverberg spent three years at UConn and more than 150 games in the AHL before getting a real NHL look, and he has earned it. But since he joined that line, Toronto has scored eight goals in four games and lost all four. A second line built around a 36-year-old centre and an $11.5 million winger needs a player who can carry the puck into the offensive zone, not a forechecker.
McKenna is that player. The 18-year-old first overall pick set up Tavares in Chicago by pouncing on a failed clear and finding him in the slot. He has been bounced between roles all season, and we argued earlier this month that the third-line mix gave him the wrong linemates. Moving him up and sliding Tverberg to a checking role with Nick Paul puts both players where their skills fit.
There is a sheltering argument for keeping McKenna on the third line. It made sense in October. It makes less sense when the second line is not producing and the team has lost seven in a row. Put the best offensive players together and let them try.
Change 3: Brendan Brisson Plays
Brisson was recalled on Nov. 12 and was a healthy scratch in Chicago. Toronto has scored three goals or fewer in every game since his recall. He was a 2020 first-round pick, he has a scoring touch the depth lineup does not, and he is already here. We argued that he deserved the job back on Nov. 14, when free agent Luke Kunin was cleared to sign, in our Brisson column.
Who comes out is Hiller's call, and that is where "some rope" matters. A coach who says some players have been given too much leeway is, by definition, describing players who are still in the lineup. Brisson in for a depth forward who has not produced is the most direct way to show the message was real.
Change 4: Give Chris Tanev a Lighter Load
Tanev turns 37 next month. The Leafs have Tanev on a load-management plan, and TSN reported that he was frustrated by it. We said at the time that Chayka was right even if Tanev hates it. In Chicago, The Leafs Nation's postgame takeaways singled out Tanev's night as part of a poor defensive effort. With Rielly back and two home games in three days, Kings on Thursday and Columbus on Saturday, there is room to dress Cole McWard for one of the two games and keep Tanev fresher for December.
This is not a demotion. Tanev's value is in hard minutes against top lines, and that value drops when he is tired. Managing him through a soft part of the schedule is how the team gets the best version of him later.
What Not to Change
Keep Cowan with Matthews. He scored on three shots in Chicago and played 20:29, per Toronto Hockey Daily, and he has been one of the steadier forwards on the roster all season. The 21-year-old's line was the one part of Tuesday that clearly worked.
Do not panic on the defence pairs beyond Tanev's minutes. Rielly just came back and needs a few games to find his timing. Change too much at once and Hiller loses the ability to tell what worked.
And do not wait on Kirill Marchenko. He skated in full gear on Nov. 16 and Chayka called him "week-to-week but starting to see an end in sight," but the injury report has him out until at least Nov. 23. He will help the top six when he is back. The Leafs cannot keep losing until he is.
What's Next
Toronto plays the Kings (6-11-2) on Thursday and the Columbus Blue Jackets on Saturday, both at home, and TSN had both teams in the bottom four of the league this week. We preview Thursday's game in our Maple Leafs vs Kings preview. If Hiller makes real changes and the Leafs still lose both, Chayka will have a harder question to answer. If he makes none, the question answers itself.
The coach said it might be time. It is. The lineup card on Thursday will show whether he believes it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Jim Hiller say about lineup changes after the Blackhawks loss?
After the 6-3 loss in Chicago on Nov. 17, 2026, Hiller said it 'might be time' for changes and 'we certainly gotta talk about it.' He added that the staff had 'given some guys some rope and let them run with it a little bit,' without naming players.
Who is on the Maple Leafs' second line?
Against Chicago on Nov. 17, John Tavares centred Ryan Tverberg and William Nylander, per NHL.com's projected lineup. Tverberg was recalled from the Marlies on Nov. 10 after Colton Sissons was injured.
Who is the Maple Leafs' starting goalie?
Sergei Bobrovsky has started more often, but he is 3-9-2 and allowed six goals on 25 shots in Chicago on Nov. 17. Anthony Stolarz is 5-4-0 with a .906 save percentage. Hiller had not named a starter for the Nov. 19 game against the Kings as of Nov. 18.
When was Brendan Brisson called up by the Maple Leafs?
Toronto recalled Brendan Brisson from the Marlies on Nov. 12, 2026. He was a healthy scratch for the Nov. 17 game in Chicago, along with defencemen Cole McWard and Dakota Mermis.
How long is the Maple Leafs' losing streak?
Seven games, all regulation losses, after the 6-3 defeat in Chicago on Nov. 17, 2026. Per The Associated Press, it is Toronto's longest losing streak since March 2015, and it dropped the team to 8-13-2.
When is Kirill Marchenko coming back?
Marchenko skated in full gear on Nov. 16, and GM John Chayka said he is week-to-week but 'starting to see an end in sight.' The team's injury report lists him out until at least Nov. 23.
