Skip to main content
Ivan Miroshnichenko Trade: Leafs Should Call Washington, Not Pay a First

Photo: NHL.com

Opinion

Ivan Miroshnichenko Trade: Leafs Should Call Washington, Not Pay a First

LeafsLurkerNov 10, 20267 min read

Table of Contents

The Ivan Miroshnichenko Trade Case for Toronto

An Ivan Miroshnichenko trade is the kind of low-cost swing the Maple Leafs should be taking right now. The Washington Capitals gave the 22-year-old winger permission to seek a trade, Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman reported on Oct. 24. He has not played since Oct. 20, his agent says he wants a top-six role somewhere else, and he carries a $925,000 cap hit through 2027-28. Toronto is 8-9-2, has scored four goals in three November games, and needs forwards. The fit is obvious. The price is the problem.

Our position: GM John Chayka should make the call, but he should not pay what Washington is asking. Here is why.

Who Is Ivan Miroshnichenko?

Miroshnichenko is a left winger from Ussuriysk, Russia, born Feb. 4, 2004. Washington took him 20th overall in the 2022 draft, months after he was diagnosed with Hodgkin's lymphoma. He completed treatment, came to North America and made his NHL debut in December 2023. His story is one of the better ones in the sport.

His NHL résumé is thin. Here is how his time with the Capitals and their AHL affiliate in Hershey breaks down, per HockeyDB, Dobber Prospects and Capitals coverage:

SeasonTeamGPPoints
2023-24Washington212 G, 4 A
2025-26Washington132 G, 1 A
2025-26Hershey (AHL)3812 G, 19 A
2026-27Washington3 (late Oct.)1 G

That is a player who has been productive in the AHL and has not been given, or has not earned, a regular NHL role. He has been a healthy scratch for most of Washington's season and was averaging a little over 11 minutes in the games he did play, per reports.

What Washington Wants

Friedman reported that the Capitals will only move Miroshnichenko for a "legit return," and that putting him on waivers is not an option. On the 32 Thoughts podcast, he compared the situation to Columbus trading Yegor Chinakhov, another young Russian winger who wanted out. Jeff Marek reported that Washington's asking price is at least a first-round pick, and that the Capitals would prefer to move him out of the Eastern Conference.

David Pagnotta of The Fourth Period listed Chicago, Vancouver, Philadelphia, Seattle, Calgary and Los Angeles as teams with interest. Toronto was not on that list. A Nov. 6 Yahoo Sports piece floated the Leafs as a possible landing spot, but it also said there was no sign the two teams had talked. Treat any Toronto connection as speculation for now.

His agent, Dan Milstein, has been clear. He said the goal is to find a team where Miroshnichenko "would have an opportunity to play in a top-six role," per Russian Machine Never Breaks on Nov. 5.

A Difficult Situation in Washington

None of this is a knock on how Miroshnichenko has handled it. Capitals head coach Spencer Carbery called it "a difficult situation" and said he was "really impressed" with the winger's attitude through the healthy scratches and trade talk, per Russian Machine Never Breaks on Oct. 26. That is worth something. A player who keeps working while he sits is easier to fit into a new room than one who has checked out.

Washington's problem is simple: it has more NHL wingers than lineup spots, and Miroshnichenko has fallen behind them. That is a roster crunch, not proof that he cannot play. Teams that buy players in this spot sometimes get a bargain, because the selling team has already decided it will not use him.

That is also why the Capitals' leverage is weaker than their asking price suggests. Every week he sits, his value to other teams drops, and Washington has ruled out waivers. At some point the price has to come down to meet the market.

Why He Fits the Leafs

Start with the cap. Toronto opened the season with about $7 million in cap space, per the Leafs contracts page, and any significant addition has to fit around a roster that is heavy at the top. A winger at $925,000 for this season and next fits under any cap structure. He would be a restricted free agent when his deal expires, so Toronto would keep his rights.

Then the need. Marchenko is out until at least Nov. 17. Jack Roslovic and Colton Sissons are day-to-day. Toronto was shut out by New Jersey on Nov. 8 and has not scored more than two goals in a game this month. Hiller is short of wingers who can play with skill players. Miroshnichenko's AHL numbers, 31 points in 38 games last season, suggest he can at least create offence against professional competition.

And the opportunity. Toronto can offer something Washington will not: minutes. A player asking for a top-six role is not going to walk into one on a healthy Leafs team, but this is not a healthy Leafs team. There is a real audition available on the second or third line right now.

Why the Price Has to Stay Low

A first-round pick for a player with a thin NHL résumé and a handful of NHL goals is too much. For the Leafs, it is close to impossible. Toronto's own 2027 first belongs to Boston from the Brandon Carlo trade. The only first the Leafs hold in that draft is Colorado's, and it is top-10 protected. That pick is Chayka's best chip for a bigger move, most likely the top-four defenceman the club has been chasing. Spending it on a long-shot winger would be a mistake. The Leafs draft pick tracker lays out every pick and condition.

The right offer is a second-round pick or a mid-tier prospect. Toronto holds its own 2027 second. If Washington wants a first, let it get one from a team with more of them. The Capitals' leverage also shrinks every week he sits in the press box. A player who is not playing loses value, and Washington knows waivers are not an option.

The other obstacle is Washington's reported preference to trade him out of the East. That may push Toronto's price up even if Chayka is interested. Our view is that the Leafs should make a fair offer and be willing to walk away.

The Risk Is Small, the Upside Is Real

The downside of a Miroshnichenko trade is easy to see. He might be a tweener: too good for the AHL, not good enough to hold a regular NHL spot. Plenty of first-round wingers end up there. If that happens, Toronto has lost a second-round pick and some depth.

The upside is a cost-controlled winger in his early 20s who gets a real chance in a lineup that needs scoring. Players in his situation sometimes take off after a change of scenery. Chinakhov is the comparison Friedman used for a reason. Toronto already took a bigger swing on a Russian winger this fall when it traded Matthew Knies for Marchenko. This would be a much smaller one.

What's Next

Nothing suggests a deal is close. Washington has interest from at least six teams, and the Capitals' price is high. But Chayka said in late October that he was open to more trades, which we covered in our look at Chayka's trade plans. And on Monday we argued that the Leafs need a forward now.

Miroshnichenko is not the answer to that problem by himself. He is a cheap test that could become part of one. Make the call, offer a second, and do not touch the Colorado first.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Ivan Miroshnichenko being traded?

The Washington Capitals gave Ivan Miroshnichenko permission to seek a trade, Elliotte Friedman reported on Oct. 24, 2026. No deal had been reported as of Nov. 10, and Washington has said it wants a legitimate return rather than putting him on waivers.

What is Ivan Miroshnichenko's contract?

Miroshnichenko is on a two-year, $1.85 million contract with a $925,000 cap hit that runs through the 2027-28 season. He will be a restricted free agent when it expires.

What do the Capitals want for Ivan Miroshnichenko?

Jeff Marek reported that Washington's asking price is at least a first-round pick and that the Capitals would prefer to trade him out of the Eastern Conference. Friedman compared the situation to Columbus trading Yegor Chinakhov.

Which teams are interested in Ivan Miroshnichenko?

David Pagnotta of The Fourth Period listed the Chicago Blackhawks, Vancouver Canucks, Philadelphia Flyers, Seattle Kraken, Calgary Flames and Los Angeles Kings as interested. The Maple Leafs were not on that list, and any Toronto link is speculation.

How old is Ivan Miroshnichenko?

Ivan Miroshnichenko was born Feb. 4, 2004, in Ussuriysk, Russia, making him 22 in November 2026. Washington drafted him 20th overall in 2022, months after he was diagnosed with Hodgkin's lymphoma.

Do the Maple Leafs have a 2027 first-round pick?

Toronto's own 2027 first-round pick belongs to Boston from the Brandon Carlo trade. The Leafs hold Colorado's 2027 first from the Nicolas Roy trade, which is top-10 protected.

Share this article